The document discusses the city planning of Chandigarh, India. It describes how Le Corbusier revised the initial plan by Albert Mayer, dividing the city into sectors of about 1200 by 800 meters. Each sector was designed as an autonomous neighborhood with housing, schools, shops, and recreational spaces. The capital complex was shifted to a higher ground and designed according to Le Corbusier's philosophies. While the planning approach was praised for creating a well-organized city, it was also criticized for being too standardized and not reflecting Indian culture and ways of life. The document analyzes the planning concepts and provides an overview of the development of Chandigarh.
ENGLISH 7_Q4_LESSON 2_ Employing a Variety of Strategies for Effective Interp...
Planning of Chandigarh City by Le Corbusier
1. City Planning
Of Chandigarh
A Discussion
Department of Architecture and
Regional Planning, IIT Kharagpur
Presented By
Sandeep Verma
16AR60R18
2. Aim
Department of Architecture and
Regional Planning, IIT Kharagpur
To study the city planning of Chandigarh.
Objective
• To understand historic background and planning concept of
Chandigarh.
• To analyse the pros and cons of planning Chandigarh.
• To understand the planning approach for a new city
planning.
Scope
• Study deals with planning took place in initial phase.
• Study is not a detailed investigation of any specific aspect.
• Study is rather qualitative in approach with study of criticism
of various researchers.
• Study focusing on sector planning and capital complex.
Limitations
• Study doesn’t relate to other works of Le Corbusier.
• Study doesn’t deal with the present urban issues of
Chandigarh.
• Study does not deal with the city evolution over the time or
the challenges encountering.
3. Overview
• Historical Background
• Mayer’s Plan
• Corbusier’s intervention and revised
plan
• Discussion on Sector
• Conception of plan as Human body
• Road Network Planning
• Capitol complex Discussion
• Critical Review
• Conclusion
4. Background
Source:
Department of Architecture and
Regional Planning, IIT Kharagpur
1947
Malik, B. (2004). City Planning and Realities: A Case Study of Chandigarh.
International Conference on "City Futures". Chicago : University of Illinois.
India’s Partition
6. “Let this be a new town, symbolic of freedom of India unfettered
by the traditions of the past. An expression of the nations faith in the
future”
JAWAHARLAL NEHRU
7. About Site
Source:
• Mountainous region
• Central location
• Natural drainage
• Sufficient water supply
• Foothills of Shivalik
• Moderate climate
• sub mountainous area of the Ambala district
• 150 miles north of New Delhi
• Flatter Area
• gentle sloping plain of agriculture land dotted with grooves of mango trees
• consisting of 59 villages
Department of Architecture and
Regional Planning, IIT Kharagpur
Fry, E. M., & B, J. D. (1955, April 1). Chandigarh and planning
development in India. Royal Society of Arts, 103(4948), 315-333.
8. New Capital City and Administration Centre
accommodating half a million people and expandable to
1 million.
9. Mayer’s Plan
Albert Mayer and Mathew Nowicky
• Located between two boundary rivers
• fan shaped plan
• Govt. Centre – Northeast Side of the City
• Super Block - Accommodating some 1500
families.
• 3 Superblocks to make a district
• Industrial area planned in southern corner
• Administration area in north-east
• 2 Large parkland zones across city
• Future expansion in the southwest across the
plan
1500 feet
3000 Feet
Sukhna
River
Patiala Rao
Administration
Complex
SUPERBLOCK
Neighbourhood Unit Concept
Criticism – Lacks Monumental Symbolism
Department of Architecture and
Regional Planning, IIT Kharagpur
Mayer’s Plan for Chandigarh
Source:
11. Le Corbusier’s Intervention
Formulation of new plan
• Kept orientation of grids as it was
• One dominant off centred doglegged axis
• The grid of superblock increased in size to
1200 x 800mts (3900 x 2700 feet)
• Accommodating up to 25000 inhabitants
• Within superblock centralized market was
replaced by continuous bazar street across
the block.
• Capital Complex and high court combined
in one govt. complex
• CBD Area Remained the same
• Shifted Capital complex to higher ground
• Two linear parks were replaced by total of 6
later by 8.
• Each Sector with its own green space around
which houses are designed
• V7 Road Concept
Leisure Valley
Capitol Complex
V1
Industrial
Areas
Sukhna
River
Patiala
Rao River
800m
1200m
Department of Architecture and
Regional Planning, IIT Kharagpur
Source: Joshi, K. (1999). Documenting Chandigarh: The Indian Architecture of Pierre
Jeanneret, Edwin Maxwell Fry, and Jane Beverly Drew, Vol. 1. Maping Publishing.
12. Sectors
V3
V4
Shops
School
Health
Centre
Arrom
hotel
School
V5
• Total 30 sectors - 24 residential
• 70% building private
• Autonomous unit including
housing, school, shops,
recreational spaces.
• 3000-25000 accommodating
capacity
• Surrounded by high speed
roads
• Bus stops every 400mts
• No pedestrian needs to walk
more than 10 minutes
Department of Architecture and
Regional Planning, IIT Kharagpur
Joshi, K. (1999). Documenting Chandigarh: The
Indian Architecture of Pierre Jeanneret, Edwin
Maxwell Fry, and Jane Beverly Drew, Vol. 1. Maping
Publishing.
Source: Joshi, K. (1999). Documenting Chandigarh: The Indian Architecture of Pierre Jeanneret,
Edwin Maxwell Fry, and Jane Beverly Drew, Vol. 1. Maping Publishing.
Sector Plan
13. Criticism
Department of Architecture and
Regional Planning, IIT Kharagpur
• Self contained sectors – All essential services within walking
distance.
• Sectors provide safe space for children.
• Safe, Yet boring
• Confusing Streets.
• Discouraging Place to go for walk.
• Un-Indian and yet inspiration of architects.
Lack in Characteristics
• Street Culture.
• Excitement of Indian cities.
• Noise of Lahore.
• Intimacy of Delhi.
A STAY-HOME CITY
Source- Kalia, R. (1985). Chandigarh: A Planned City. Habitat International,
9, 135-150.
Sector Plan
Source: Joshi, K. (1999). Documenting Chandigarh: The Indian Architecture of Pierre
Jeanneret, Edwin Maxwell Fry, and Jane Beverly Drew, Vol. 1. Maping Publishing.
14. City totally European
Designed without regard of fierce north Indian climate or
Indian ways of life.
City segregated by income, and civil ranks
Inappropriate decision of hiring western designers to plan
cities for non western culture
Sector 17 - not valued much as would have valued in
Europe
Decorative
Peter Hall
Department of Architecture and
Regional Planning, IIT Kharagpur
Source - Turner, T. (Director). (2015). Chandigarh 1 (of 4): Le Corbusier’s urban
design and planning [Motion Picture].
15. Philosophy
Brain - Capitol Complex
Heart – City centre (Sector 17)
Lungs – Leisure valley
Intellect – Educational Areas
Veins - Circulation System V7
Viscera – Industrial area
N
Department of Architecture and
Regional Planning, IIT Kharagpur
18. V2 MAJOR BOULEVARDS
V3 SECTOR DEFINERS
Department of Architecture and
Regional Planning, IIT Kharagpur
City A City A
19. V4 SHOPPING STREETS
V5 CIRCULATION ROAD
WITHIN SECTORS
N
V6 PROVIDING ACCESS TO THE
HOUSES
Department of Architecture and
Regional Planning, IIT Kharagpur
V5
23. Source - Turner, T. (Director). (2015). Chandigarh 1 (of 4): Le Corbusier’s urban
design and planning [Motion Picture].
Plan of Chandigarh
24. Source - Turner, T. (Director). (2015). Chandigarh 1 (of 4): Le Corbusier’s urban
design and planning [Motion Picture].
Department of Architecture and
Regional Planning, IIT Kharagpur
Shows Corbusier's interest in
symbols.
Capital landscape as a sacred
place with layers of cosmic
significance
Complex as head of
vastupurush.
linked the site as microcosm
with the cosmos.
25. Source - Turner, T. (Director). (2015). Chandigarh 1 (of 4): Le Corbusier’s urban
design and planning [Motion Picture].
Department of Architecture and
Regional Planning, IIT Kharagpur
26. Tower of Shadows
High court Building
Assembly Building Secretariat Building Pedestrian Plaza
Source - Turner, T. (Director). (2015). Chandigarh 1 (of 4): Le Corbusier’s urban
design and planning [Motion Picture].
Department of Architecture and
Regional Planning, IIT Kharagpur
27. Source - Turner, T. (Director). (2015). Chandigarh 1 (of 4): Le Corbusier’s urban
design and planning [Motion Picture].
High Court Building
28. Source - Turner, T. (Director). (2015). Chandigarh 1 (of 4): Le Corbusier’s urban
design and planning [Motion Picture].
Assembly Building with giant plaza
29. A great pedestrian plaza which embodies spirit of exultation, power and permanence, experienced by Indians
on acquiring self governance.
• Neglected space and Empty
• Area treated as high security zone and
controlled by military
• Emptier than intended
• Museum of knowledge ( Governors palace)
never built
• Huge Expense
Corbusier to be blamed?
Source - Turner, T. (Director). (2015). Chandigarh 1 (of 4): Le Corbusier’s urban
design and planning [Motion Picture].
Department of Architecture and
Regional Planning, IIT Kharagpur
30. Martus Memorial
Source - Turner, T. (Director). (2015). Chandigarh 1 (of 4): Le Corbusier’s urban design and planning [Motion Picture].
31. Swastika Symbol
Source - Turner, T. (Director). (2015). Chandigarh 1 (of 4): Le Corbusier’s urban design and planning [Motion Picture].
32. Source - Turner, T. (Director). (2015). Chandigarh 1 (of 4): Le Corbusier’s urban design and planning [Motion Picture].
Open Hand
33. Trench of Consideration
Source - Turner, T. (Director). (2015). Chandigarh 1 (of 4): Le Corbusier’s urban design and planning [Motion Picture].
35. Ideal Cities
Amarna by Akhenaten
Fatehpur Sikri, Akbar
Brazilia by Oscar Niemeyer and Lucio costa
Broadacre city, FLW
Radiant city, Le corbusier
Chandigarh
Wealthiest town of India.
No 1 in terms of Human Development Index.
3rd highest GDP growth rate 9.64%.
Cleanest and Greenest City in India.
Good Governance- A compact, efficient Administration having
Quick Decision making system
(Over a million population )
36. Conclusions
1. Technology should be part of planning process, shouldn’t be the basis of it.
2. City as settlement of community can not be standardize as the multiple of
“generic” like sectors.
3. New city planning should establish the relationship of site with people and
their roots who put soul to the city otherwise it’s a dead city.
4. People must be given expression in terms of planning and designing where
they live in or where they work.
5. Urban character can only come out of collective will of people
6. Icon status is not achieved by city due to designers vocabulary it is achieved
by the adaptiveness of people.
37. 1.Shaw, A. (2009). Town Planning in Post Colonial India, 1947-1965: Chandigarh Re-Examined . Urban Geography
, 857-876.
2.Fry, E. M., & B, J. D. (1955, April 1). Chandigarh and planning development in India. Royal Society of Arts,
103(4948), 315-333.
3.Malik, B. (2004). City Planning and Realities: A Case Study of Chandigarh. International Conference on "City
Futures". Chicago : University of Illinois.
4. Fitting, P. (2002). Urban Planning/Utopian Dreaming Le Corbusier's Chandigarh Today. Utopian Studies, 69-93.
5.Gethin, C. (1973). Chandigarh: A memorial to arrogance. Built Environment, 291-294.
6.Kalia, R. (1985). Chandigarh: A Planned City. Habitat International, 9, 135-150.
7.Morris, A. E. (1975). Chandigarh: The plan Corb tore up? Built Environment Quarterly December , 229-234.
8.Turner, T. (Director). (2015). Chandigarh 1 (of 4): Le Corbusier’s urban design and planning [Motion Picture].
9. D'Souza, V. S. (1976, Sept 18). People Prevail over Plan. Economic and Political Weekly Vol 11 No.11(38), 1626-
1528.
10. Joshi, K. (1999). Documenting Chandigarh: The Indian Architecture of Pierre Jeanneret, Edwin Maxwell Fry,
and Jane Beverly Drew, Vol. 1. Maping Publishing.
References
38. Thank You
Source - Turner, T. (Director). (2015). Chandigarh 1 (of 4): Le Corbusier’s urban
design and planning [Motion Picture].