SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 8
The role of violence in Act 3,
scene 7
Violence in Greek tragedy
• Many ancient Greek tragedians employed
the ekkyklêma as a theatrical device, which was
a platform hidden behind the scene that could be
rolled out to display the aftermath of some event
which had happened out of sight of the
audience.
• This event was frequently a brutal murder of
some sort, an act of violence which could not be
effectively portrayed visually, but an action of
which the other characters must see the effects
in order for it to have meaning and emotional
resonance.
• Variations on the ekkyklêma are used in
tragedies and other forms to this day, as writers
still find it a useful and often powerful device for
showing the consequences of extreme human
actions.
Portrayal of violence
• There were constraints to portraying violence:
– the audience must never witness any act or occurrence that impinged
on a human or animal body so as to be the proximate cause of a death
– the audience must not witness any person inflicting a blow on any
other person.
• The first convention was based on religious considerations, and was
unbreakable; the second was based on artistic considerations
• However, violence could be presented verbally, through
‘messenger‐speeches’ or other forms of narrative, with virtually no
limits on the intensity of the horrors described; nor were the
dramatists in the least squeamish about presenting on stage
the results of violence in the most appalling form—the blinded
Oedipus or Polymestor, the dismembered corpse of Pentheus, Aias
amidst the animals he has tortured and slaughtered or the agonies
that Prometheus is suffering.
Think!
What is genuinely disturbing/acceptable in a
live theatrical performance?
Key question –AO2
How is the violence of
this scene is
conveyed through
language (imagery,
figurative language,
line length, caesura,
punctuation)?
Key question - AO3
Why might Shakespeare have
wanted his audience to
endure the blinding of
Gloucester?
Critical starting point...
Wilson Knight in the chapter called "King Lear and the Comedy of the
Grotesque'' in his book The Wheel of Fire (1930) writes:
The gouging out of Gloucester's eyes is a thing unnecessary, crude,
disgusting; it is meant to be. It helps to provide an accompanying
exaggeration of one element --- that of cruelty --- in the horror that
makes Lear's madness. And not only horror: there is even again
something satanically comic bedded deep within it. The sight of
physical torment, to the uneducated, brings laughter. Shakespeare's
England delighted in watching both physical torment and the comic
ravings of actual lunacy. These ghoulish horrors, so popular in
Elizabethan drama and the very stuff of the Lear of Shakespeare's
youth, Titus Andronicus, find an exquisitely appropriate place in the
tragedy of Shakespeare's maturity which takes as its especial
province the territory of the grotesque and the fantastic which is
Lear's madness.
Summing up
• Eyes/ vision are key motifs in
the play.
– Where else do they occur?
– What is the symbolic
significance?

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Was ist angesagt? (19)

The History Of Horror Films
The History Of Horror FilmsThe History Of Horror Films
The History Of Horror Films
 
The History Of Horror Films
The History Of Horror FilmsThe History Of Horror Films
The History Of Horror Films
 
Gothic horror
Gothic horrorGothic horror
Gothic horror
 
Genre research black comedy luke o'donnell
Genre research black comedy luke o'donnellGenre research black comedy luke o'donnell
Genre research black comedy luke o'donnell
 
British Comedy
British ComedyBritish Comedy
British Comedy
 
Zombies
ZombiesZombies
Zombies
 
Vampires Over Time
Vampires Over TimeVampires Over Time
Vampires Over Time
 
The Representations of Vampires
The Representations of VampiresThe Representations of Vampires
The Representations of Vampires
 
Analysis of an existing short film
Analysis of an existing short filmAnalysis of an existing short film
Analysis of an existing short film
 
Horror Genre Presentation
Horror Genre PresentationHorror Genre Presentation
Horror Genre Presentation
 
Vert 7 - Ebert on hitchcock
Vert 7 - Ebert on hitchcockVert 7 - Ebert on hitchcock
Vert 7 - Ebert on hitchcock
 
Leslie thomas
Leslie thomasLeslie thomas
Leslie thomas
 
The history of horror films
The history of horror filmsThe history of horror films
The history of horror films
 
Making the Movie Genuine - Director MarieAnna Dvorak
Making the Movie Genuine - Director MarieAnna DvorakMaking the Movie Genuine - Director MarieAnna Dvorak
Making the Movie Genuine - Director MarieAnna Dvorak
 
The History of Horror
The History of HorrorThe History of Horror
The History of Horror
 
BEA2014 - Corso
BEA2014 - CorsoBEA2014 - Corso
BEA2014 - Corso
 
Horror6
Horror6Horror6
Horror6
 
Subgenre explanation
Subgenre explanationSubgenre explanation
Subgenre explanation
 
Irony and Paradox
Irony and ParadoxIrony and Paradox
Irony and Paradox
 

Ähnlich wie Violence in greek tragedy

Elements of greek tragedy and the tragic hero
Elements of greek tragedy and the tragic heroElements of greek tragedy and the tragic hero
Elements of greek tragedy and the tragic herocafeharmon
 
English 412 (disregard the first two slides {title and pointers})
English 412 (disregard the first two slides {title and  pointers})English 412 (disregard the first two slides {title and  pointers})
English 412 (disregard the first two slides {title and pointers})Kostyk Elf
 
A Funny Incident Essay
A Funny Incident EssayA Funny Incident Essay
A Funny Incident EssayRegina Mendez
 
Transcending Nihilism in The Hairy Ape Revised
Transcending Nihilism in The Hairy Ape RevisedTranscending Nihilism in The Hairy Ape Revised
Transcending Nihilism in The Hairy Ape RevisedAlexander Booth
 
Wagner roy2010 coyote anthropology
Wagner roy2010 coyote anthropologyWagner roy2010 coyote anthropology
Wagner roy2010 coyote anthropologyAriel Nunes
 

Ähnlich wie Violence in greek tragedy (6)

Elements of greek tragedy and the tragic hero
Elements of greek tragedy and the tragic heroElements of greek tragedy and the tragic hero
Elements of greek tragedy and the tragic hero
 
English 412 (disregard the first two slides {title and pointers})
English 412 (disregard the first two slides {title and  pointers})English 412 (disregard the first two slides {title and  pointers})
English 412 (disregard the first two slides {title and pointers})
 
A Funny Incident Essay
A Funny Incident EssayA Funny Incident Essay
A Funny Incident Essay
 
Transcending Nihilism in The Hairy Ape Revised
Transcending Nihilism in The Hairy Ape RevisedTranscending Nihilism in The Hairy Ape Revised
Transcending Nihilism in The Hairy Ape Revised
 
Wagner roy2010 coyote anthropology
Wagner roy2010 coyote anthropologyWagner roy2010 coyote anthropology
Wagner roy2010 coyote anthropology
 
A Survey Of Tragedy
A Survey Of TragedyA Survey Of Tragedy
A Survey Of Tragedy
 

Mehr von Samantha Peplow

Mehr von Samantha Peplow (20)

CORDELIA
CORDELIACORDELIA
CORDELIA
 
APPEARANCE AND REALITY
APPEARANCE AND REALITYAPPEARANCE AND REALITY
APPEARANCE AND REALITY
 
CHAOS AND DISINTEGRATION
CHAOS AND DISINTEGRATIONCHAOS AND DISINTEGRATION
CHAOS AND DISINTEGRATION
 
THE HOVEL
THE HOVELTHE HOVEL
THE HOVEL
 
THE STORM
THE STORMTHE STORM
THE STORM
 
HOVEL PART 2
HOVEL PART 2HOVEL PART 2
HOVEL PART 2
 
EXAMPLE ESSAY PLAN JUSTICE
EXAMPLE ESSAY PLAN JUSTICEEXAMPLE ESSAY PLAN JUSTICE
EXAMPLE ESSAY PLAN JUSTICE
 
EXAMPLE ESSAY PLAN EDMUND
EXAMPLE ESSAY PLAN EDMUNDEXAMPLE ESSAY PLAN EDMUND
EXAMPLE ESSAY PLAN EDMUND
 
Family relationships in lear
Family relationships in learFamily relationships in lear
Family relationships in lear
 
Women in king lear and gloucester prep
Women in king lear  and gloucester prepWomen in king lear  and gloucester prep
Women in king lear and gloucester prep
 
The storm in lear
The storm in learThe storm in lear
The storm in lear
 
King lear essay questions
King lear essay questionsKing lear essay questions
King lear essay questions
 
Family relationships in lear
Family relationships in learFamily relationships in lear
Family relationships in lear
 
King lear question inspiration
King lear question inspirationKing lear question inspiration
King lear question inspiration
 
King lear revision presentation
King lear revision presentationKing lear revision presentation
King lear revision presentation
 
Om&m full text - four
Om&m   full text - fourOm&m   full text - four
Om&m full text - four
 
Ella 2 revision materials
Ella 2 revision materialsElla 2 revision materials
Ella 2 revision materials
 
The stocks
The stocksThe stocks
The stocks
 
Sentence starters
Sentence startersSentence starters
Sentence starters
 
Conflict cluster revision_aqa
Conflict cluster revision_aqaConflict cluster revision_aqa
Conflict cluster revision_aqa
 

Violence in greek tragedy

  • 1. The role of violence in Act 3, scene 7
  • 2. Violence in Greek tragedy • Many ancient Greek tragedians employed the ekkyklêma as a theatrical device, which was a platform hidden behind the scene that could be rolled out to display the aftermath of some event which had happened out of sight of the audience. • This event was frequently a brutal murder of some sort, an act of violence which could not be effectively portrayed visually, but an action of which the other characters must see the effects in order for it to have meaning and emotional resonance. • Variations on the ekkyklêma are used in tragedies and other forms to this day, as writers still find it a useful and often powerful device for showing the consequences of extreme human actions.
  • 3. Portrayal of violence • There were constraints to portraying violence: – the audience must never witness any act or occurrence that impinged on a human or animal body so as to be the proximate cause of a death – the audience must not witness any person inflicting a blow on any other person. • The first convention was based on religious considerations, and was unbreakable; the second was based on artistic considerations • However, violence could be presented verbally, through ‘messenger‐speeches’ or other forms of narrative, with virtually no limits on the intensity of the horrors described; nor were the dramatists in the least squeamish about presenting on stage the results of violence in the most appalling form—the blinded Oedipus or Polymestor, the dismembered corpse of Pentheus, Aias amidst the animals he has tortured and slaughtered or the agonies that Prometheus is suffering.
  • 4. Think! What is genuinely disturbing/acceptable in a live theatrical performance?
  • 5. Key question –AO2 How is the violence of this scene is conveyed through language (imagery, figurative language, line length, caesura, punctuation)?
  • 6. Key question - AO3 Why might Shakespeare have wanted his audience to endure the blinding of Gloucester?
  • 7. Critical starting point... Wilson Knight in the chapter called "King Lear and the Comedy of the Grotesque'' in his book The Wheel of Fire (1930) writes: The gouging out of Gloucester's eyes is a thing unnecessary, crude, disgusting; it is meant to be. It helps to provide an accompanying exaggeration of one element --- that of cruelty --- in the horror that makes Lear's madness. And not only horror: there is even again something satanically comic bedded deep within it. The sight of physical torment, to the uneducated, brings laughter. Shakespeare's England delighted in watching both physical torment and the comic ravings of actual lunacy. These ghoulish horrors, so popular in Elizabethan drama and the very stuff of the Lear of Shakespeare's youth, Titus Andronicus, find an exquisitely appropriate place in the tragedy of Shakespeare's maturity which takes as its especial province the territory of the grotesque and the fantastic which is Lear's madness.
  • 8. Summing up • Eyes/ vision are key motifs in the play. – Where else do they occur? – What is the symbolic significance?