I gave this talk at Content Marketing World 2014. It talks about a content strategy practice - content auditing - and how it can benefit content marketing efforts. It includes links to some useful tools and resources.
What I learned from auditing over 1,000,000 websites - SERP Conf 2024 Patrick...
Â
Content Auditing: Unearthing the Substance of Your Brand
1. #CMWorld
Content Auditing:
Unearthing the Substance of Your Brand
Rachel Lovinger
Experience Director, Razorfish
@rlovinger
2. #CMWorld
2
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Iâm here to share some practical processes, tools and tips for auditing your content.
Photo by Matthew Macy (link)
3. #CMWorld
3
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Experience Director/ Content Strategist, Razorfish
â˘scatter/gather(content strategy blog): http://scattergather.razorfish.com
â˘Nimble: A Razorfish Report on Publishing in the Digital Age(June 2010): http://nimble.razorfish.com
About me: Rachel Lovinger
@rlovinger
4. #CMWorld
4
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Razorfish views digital as not solely a marketing channel but an opportunity to go to market in new and powerful ways.
â˘We blend creativity, technology and media, supported by consumer and business insights, to delivering for our clients in both marketing (ideas) and technology (execution).
About Razorfish
Media
Creative
Technology
Business Strategy & Insight
TRANSFORMATION
Disruption
6. #CMWorld
6
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Financial services client
â˘Small Business offerings
â˘âWe have a ton of contentâ
A social marketing strategy project
Photo by Alan Reeves
7. #CMWorld
7
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
The reality of their content situation
30 PDFs
3 Videos
8. #CMWorld
8
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
After the 33 content items, we looked at:
â˘The broader landscape of content available for Small Business owners
â˘Content offered by our clientâs direct competitors
Result:
We were able to make better recommendations about underserved needs and untapped opportunities.
The content audit was brief
10. #CMWorld
10
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Text
Š Contents Magazine
11. #CMWorld
11
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Images
Š National Geographic
12. #CMWorld
12
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Audio
Š 99 Percent Invisible
13. #CMWorld
13
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Video
Š General Electric
14. #CMWorld
14
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Data
Visualization by Ramiro GĂłmez
15. #CMWorld
15
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Infographics
Infographic by tastyplacement
16. #CMWorld
16
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Airbnbâsorigin: Two guys in San Francisco rented out air mattresses in their living room.
Brand narratives
AirbnbStory as of August 2013, via Internet Archiveâs WaybackMachine
17. #CMWorld
17
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Expanded narrative: Itâs about going anywhere in the world, and having a place to feel at home.
Brand narratives
Š Airbnb, Inc.
18. #CMWorld
18
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Brand identity elements
â˘Messaging standards
â˘Design elements: logos, colors, fonts
â˘Copy standards
â˘PR/Marketing assets
â˘Templates
Brand assets
Š TED Conferences, LLC
19. #CMWorld
19
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Brand guidelines
TEDxBranding Guidelines, May 15, 2009
20. #CMWorld
20
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Content channels
www icon by Saki, GPL
21. #CMWorld
21
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Content is a dialogue
Photo by Marc Wathieu
22. #CMWorld
22
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Conversations about your brand
Archer Š FX Networks
23. #CMWorld
23
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Sometimes, damage controlJuly 16July 18Aug 11
BÊloŠ AirbnbJuly 23
24. #CMWorld
24
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Your audienceâs:
â˘Interests
â˘Questions
â˘Hopes/desires
â˘Frustrations
*Participate cautiously, respectfully, and ethically.
Conversations in your area of interest
Photo by Marc Wathieu
26. #CMWorld
26
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Thanks to digital, marketing is changing
Photo by Ruth Flickr
27. #CMWorld
27
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Paid, owned, earned = more content
Net
CMS Platform
Website Content
Offer
ALWAYS-ON PAID: SEM
EARNED
OWNED
SEO
Search engines
Organic
PAID MEDIA
Blogs
Forums
Followers
Links
LinkedIn Network
28. #CMWorld
28
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Real-time marketing = faster content
SharknadoWeatherForecast
by @dcschrader, @redcrossPR Volunteer
Poop Tweet
by Razorfish, for @smartcarusa
(watch the case study: https://vimeo.com/58482929)
Cobalt
for @TargetStyle
29. #CMWorld
29
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
In marketing it plays a critical role in:
â˘Attracting
â˘Converting
â˘Building and maintaining loyalty
Content is the stuff people want
Photo by zandperl
30. #CMWorld
30
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Thereâs a lot of content out there
â˘It takes time, resources and planning to produce goodcontent
Content is a big deal. So what?
Data Never Sleeps infographic Š Domo; Plans photo by Sarah Ross
31. #CMWorld
31
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘What content do you have available now?
âDiscover the quantity, quality, effectiveness and perception of your content
âLearn how to better use your existing content
â˘What content do you need that you donât yet have?
âFind out what your audience wants, what theyâre getting elsewhere, and what theyâre not getting at all (yet)
What you can learn from auditing
32. #CMWorld
Itâs an iterative process
Assumptions
Information
Findings
Insights
34. #CMWorld
34
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Understand the context
âBusiness goals, audience needs, and institutional knowledge
â˘Evaluate the landscape
âCompetitive and comparative
â˘Analyze the content
âQuantity, quality, effectiveness, and perception
â˘Assess the opportunity
âNeeds and gaps
Steps to Auditing Content
35. #CMWorld
35
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Understand the context
âBusiness goals, audience needs, and institutional knowledge
â˘Evaluate the landscape
â˘Analyze the content
â˘Assess the opportunity
Steps to Auditing Content
36. #CMWorld
36
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
What are you trying to accomplish with the content?
Typical goals include:
â˘Awareness
â˘Engagement
â˘Conversion
â˘Satisfaction / Loyalty
Business goals
Photo by Rachel Lovinger
37. #CMWorld
37
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Who is your audience? What do they want from the content?
Audience needs
Ways to get information:
â˘Surveys
â˘Interviews
â˘Focus groups
â˘Personas
â˘Content testing
Backup plan: Read secondary research.
Photo by K2_UX
38. #CMWorld
38
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
What can you learn from your content stakeholders?
Ask them about:
â˘Current efforts
â˘Past attempts
â˘Complaints
â˘Requests
â˘Like & dislikes
Institutional knowledge
Photo by Amir Lodge
39. #CMWorld
39
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Understand the context
â˘Evaluate the landscape
âCompetitive and comparative
â˘Analyze the content
â˘Assess the opportunity
Steps to Auditing Content
40. #CMWorld
40
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Consider factors such as:
â˘Tone
â˘Topics
â˘Credibility
â˘Segmenting & Targeting
â˘Brand Expression
â˘Sales Approach
Look at other sources of content
Photo by David
41. #CMWorld
41
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Look at the content your competitors are producing.
â˘What types of content? Formats? Subjects?
â˘Does it seem interesting and engaging?
â˘Is it clear who itâs for?
â˘What needs is it trying to serve?
â˘Is it serving those needs?
â˘Where are they making it available?
â˘Is it unique and on brand?
Competitive content audit
42. #CMWorld
42
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Focus
Format
Overview
Instruction, Inspiration
Articles, video, tools
Digital Vanguard:Very actionable advice and tools, primarily in the realms of social media and online search. Also very on-brand.
Inspiration, Editorial Curation
Video, curated articles,events
Brand Values: Small amount of original content,highly associated with Chase values. Consistently and pervasively branded (âInk from Chaseâ).
Instructional, Inspirational,
Article,video
Practical authority:Well-organized articles. Precise but not jargon-y. Actionable information references the brand, but isnât overly sales-oriented.
Instruction, Inspiration
Articles, video
RelationshipBuilding: Reinforces the message that small business owners should engage in a one-on-one relationship with PNC.
Instruction
Video
DemonstratedExpertise: Establishes an authoritative voice on a broad spectrum of small business-related topics.
Community Curation
Articles, forum
CautionaryTale:Lots of actionable content of various types, but poorly moderated and not leveraged in any way that benefits the brand.
Instruction
Online workshops, transcripts
ContentFail: Would be better off with only product content âthis content does more harm than good to their brand image.
Instruction
Online workshops
Content Fail:Brandmessageof relationship building is wholly unsupported.
Instruction
Articles
ContentFail: Advice content is strictly focused on solving potential business problems with products and service offerings.
Competitive content audit
43. #CMWorld
43
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Look at sources that serve similar audience needs.
â˘Where else does your audience go for information on topics related to your brandâs offering?
â˘What other kinds of information is of interest to your target audience?
â˘Look at informal channels, as well as official channels.
â˘Whatâs interesting or different from the content produced by your brand and your competitors?
Comparative content audit
44. #CMWorld
44
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Instruction and Opinion
â˘Inspiration
â˘News
â˘Factual Resources
â˘Community Curation
â˘Editorial Curation
Content for small business owners
45. #CMWorld
45
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Understand the context
â˘Evaluate the landscape
â˘Analyze the content
âQuantity: How much is there?
âQuality: How good/appropriate is it?
âEffectiveness: Is it accomplishing what you need it to?
âPerception: What does your content say about your brand?
â˘Assess the opportunity
Steps to Auditing Content
46. #CMWorld
46
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Content Inventory
A list of the available content items, with related data that can be used for organizing, ranking, sorting, filtering.
Content Audit
Includes analysis and insights from qualitative analysis of the content. Can be comprehensive or a summary.
Defining documents
47. #CMWorld
47
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Understand the context
â˘Evaluate the landscape
â˘Analyze the content
âQuantity
âQuality
âEffectiveness
âPerception
â˘Assess the opportunity
Steps to Auditing Content
48. #CMWorld
48
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Consider online and offline sources
â˘Determine how comprehensive your inventory needs to be
Quantity: Content inventory
Every item
Representativeexamples
â˘Small or amount of content
â˘Need precise decisions
â˘Wide range in quality
â˘Legal or compliance constraints
â˘A ton of content (really!)
â˘Youcan learn what you need to know from looking at samples
49. #CMWorld
49
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Sample content inventory
Sample from Discovery: Content Audits, Inventories and Interviews Oh My!
by Andrew Kaufman
50. #CMWorld
50
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Name
â˘Location (URL and/or channel)
â˘Description
â˘Owner
â˘Format
âEx: Article, Video, Audio, PDF
â˘Structure or purpose
âEx: Recipe, Review, Blog post
â˘Intended audience (if variable)
â˘Date (if known)
â˘Metadata
â˘Analytics information
â˘Usage rights
â˘Anything else that will help make decisions about what to use and how to use it.
Possible fields to include
51. #CMWorld
51
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Common Metrics to Examine:
âUnique visitors (visitor level, # of people who did x)
âVisits (session level, # of times x was done)
âPage views (page level, # of times page y was seen)
âClick through rate
âConversion rate
âCompletion rate (tool, application, etc.)
âBounce rate (1 page view)
âExit rate (left site after current page view)
âRepeat vs. new visitor rate
âCustomer vs. prospect rate
âSite search rate
âUsage of navigation rate
âSite exit rate
âAverage time (on site, on page, on tool)
âAverage page views (on site, on tool)
âInitial promised amount for converters
Include analytics data
52. #CMWorld
52
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
If youâre not looking at every item of content, try to find out how much there is:
â˘In each channel
â˘Of each type
â˘On each topic
Content counts
Photo by Scott Kidder
53. #CMWorld
53
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Try Content Analysis Tool, by Content Insight
âCrawls online content
âIncorporates analytics
âEnhance data with your own further analysis
See also: Power Mapper, Screaming Frog(SEO focus), SiteOrbiter(for Macs), HTTrack(For PCs)
Inventory tools
54. #CMWorld
54
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Understand the context
â˘Evaluate the landscape
â˘Analyze the content
âQuantity
âQuality
âEffectiveness
âPerception
â˘Assess the opportunity
Steps to Auditing Content
55. #CMWorld
55
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Qualitative analysis is not just a question of âis it good?â
Look at factors such as:
â˘Clarity
â˘Tone
â˘Purpose
Quality: Beyond the numbers
Photo by ShiraGolding Evergreen
56. #CMWorld
56
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Is your content:
â˘Communicating clearly?
â˘Appropriate for your goals?
â˘Appropriate for your brand?
â˘Appropriate for your audience?
â˘Relevant to your audienceâs needs?
â˘Up-to-date?
â˘Compliant with standards & regulations?
Qualitative analysis
Inappropriate Greeting Card by tengrrl(CC-BY-SA)
57. #CMWorld
57
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Two valid ways of talking about biochemistry
Variation is to be expected
Chem4Kids.com Š Andrew Radar Studios; ACS Publications Š American Chemical Society
58. #CMWorld
58
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
A misguided experiment
59. #CMWorld
59
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Candy website restricted to people 13 or older (with a terrible disclaimer)
A self-defeating solution
60. #CMWorld
60
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
For more information on Tone & Voice, and for guidance on creating high quality content, read:
â˘Nicely Said, by Nicole Fenton and Kate Kiefer Lee
Tone & Voice
61. #CMWorld
61
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Understand the context
â˘Evaluate the landscape
â˘Analyze the content
âQuantity
âQuality
âEffectiveness
âPerception
â˘Assess the opportunity
Steps to Auditing Content
62. #CMWorld
62
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Effectiveness: Measure against goals
BusinessGoal
Potential Measurements
Awareness
â˘Page views
â˘Unique visitors
Engagement
â˘Time on page
â˘Repeat visits
â˘Social shares
Conversion
â˘Registration
â˘Email signup
â˘Downloads
â˘Purchases
Satisfaction / Loyalty
â˘Ratings
â˘Reviews
63. #CMWorld
63
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
For example:
â˘Increase perception of expertise
â˘Aid in decision making process for prospective customers
â˘Reach audience with greater influence
â˘Improve sentiment towards the brand
â˘Receive fewer calls or emails to support center
â˘Increase percentage of repeat visits
Detailed objectives
64. #CMWorld
64
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Possible approaches :
â˘Analytics reporting
â˘Social listening
â˘Scorecards
â˘Surveys
â˘Testing
Measuring content effectiveness
Photo by OllivierGirard for Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR)
65. #CMWorld
65
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Set business goals and detailed objectives
â˘Establish benchmarks
â˘Measure, optimize, and measure again
Tips for measurement
Volume and Percent of Visitors who Accessed Content
1,994
16,383
25,561
25,315
28,800
0.00%
0.20%
0.40%
0.60%
0.80%
1.00%
1.20%
1.40%
1.60%
-
5,000
10,000
15,000
20,000
25,000
30,000
35,000
Q109
Q209
Q309
Q409
Q110
% of Visitors
# of Readers
Volume of Readers
% of Visitors
66. #CMWorld
66
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
snapscore, from ContentWRX:
â˘Surveys and analytics data
â˘Tools for analyzing data
â˘Reporting to help interpret
â˘Recommendations, research, best practices, and prompts
Effectiveness measurement tools
67. #CMWorld
67
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Understand the context
â˘Evaluate the landscape
â˘Analyze the content
âQuantity
âQuality
âEffectiveness
âPerception
â˘Assess the opportunity
Steps to Auditing Content
68. #CMWorld
68
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘What does your content say about your brand?
âDoes your content express your brandâs core values?
âWhat attributes does your brand voice convey?
âWhat story is your content telling about your business?
Include questions like these in your own qualitative analysis, as well as in research with your audience and stakeholders.
Perception: Align with brand values
69. #CMWorld
69
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Who recognizes this?
Scans from Abandoned Republic, by Scott Adams
Thanks Margot Bloomstein(@mbloomstein)!
70. #CMWorld
70
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Banana Republic 2014
Š Banana Republic
71. #CMWorld
71
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Recognize this brand?
[Brand A] touches the lives of millions of people each and every day. From special occasions to exceptional moments in everyday life, [Brand A] is there. The brand has become a special part of people's lives.
Over the years, thousands of people have sent us personal stories about how [Brand A] has affected their lives. Whether it is a favorite childhood memory, a reminder of family gatherings, or a recollection of good times with friends, [Brand A] has touched the lives of people all over the world.
72. #CMWorld
72
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
Coca-Cola
[Brand A] touches the lives of millions of people each and every day. From special occasions to exceptional moments in everyday life, [Brand A] is there. The brand has become a special part of people's lives.
Over the years, thousands of people have sent us personal stories about how [Brand A] has affected their lives. Whether it is a favorite childhood memory, a reminder of family gatherings, or a recollection of good times with friends, [Brand A] has touched the lives of people all over the world.
Š The Coca-Cola Company
73. #CMWorld
73
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
At [Brand B], we believe that serving our communities is not only integral to running a business successfully, it is part of our individual responsibilities as citizens of the world. The mission of our program is to bring to life the [Brand B] value of good corporate citizenship by supporting communities in ways that enhance the company's reputation with employees, customers, business partners and other stakeholders. We do this by supporting visionary nonprofit organizations that are:
â˘Preservingand sustaining unique historic places for the future
â˘Developing newleadersfor tomorrow
â˘Encouragingcommunity servicewhere our employees and customers live and work
How about this one?
74. #CMWorld
74
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
At [Brand B], we believe that serving our communities is not only integral to running a business successfully, it is part of our individual responsibilities as citizens of the world. The mission of our program is to bring to life the [Brand B] value of good corporate citizenship by supporting communities in ways that enhance the company's reputation with employees, customers, business partners and other stakeholders. We do this by supporting visionary nonprofit organizations that are:
â˘Preservingand sustaining unique historic places for the future
â˘Developing newleadersfor tomorrow
â˘Encouragingcommunity servicewhere our employees and customers live and work
American Express
Š American Express Company
75. #CMWorld
75
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Investigate how people perceive your content
â˘Craft content that better represents the unique attributes of your brand
What are your brand values?
Need some guidance? Read Sine Qua Non
by Jonathon Colman (@jcolman): http://bit.ly/csapple
76. #CMWorld
76
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘Understand the context
â˘Evaluate the landscape
â˘Analyze the content
â˘Assess the opportunity
âNeeds and gaps
Steps to Auditing Content
77. #CMWorld
77
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
What is your audience looking for that isnât available, or that you could provide better?
Opportunity: Fill the gap
What your audience wants
Competitors
Other Sources
Opportunity
78. #CMWorld
78
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
You may already have content that fills some of those gaps. If youâve done your audit, you know what you have and youâre ready to use it.
Use your content well
Photos and pendants by Mary Anne Enriquez
79. #CMWorld
79
Š2014 Razorfish. All rights reserved.
â˘2 Critical Types of Content Analysis, by Colleen Jones (Jan 23, 2014)
â˘Content Audits and Inventories: A Handbook, by Paula Land (book, to be released September 2014)
â˘Discovery: Content Audits, Inventories and Interviews Oh My!, by Andrew Kaufman (July 9, 2013)
â˘Does Your Content Work?, by Colleen Jones (eBook, Feb 6, 2014)
â˘How To Do a Content Audit -Step-by-Step, byEverett Sizemore of Inflow, for The MozBlog (Aug 13, 2014)
â˘Inventory to Insight: Understanding Content Inventories, Audits, and Analysis, by Paula Land (webinar, Apr 18, 2014)
Want more information?