SlideShare ist ein Scribd-Unternehmen logo
1 von 47
Downloaden Sie, um offline zu lesen
RBAP-MABS National Roundtable Conference



    Evolution of the Microfinance Investment Landscape
    and Reasons behind the Growth of Social Investments
                                                       A Broad Overview


                                            By James Soukamneuth, Ph.D.
                                        Asia Office Director, Planet Rating
                                               jsoukam@planetrating.com




                                                                                                               Hyatt Hotel, Malate Manila
                                                                                                                             June 2, 2010

Planet Rating, c/o James Soukamneuth    Accredited by ADA Rating Initiative
444 EDSA, 21st floor– Guadalupe Viejo   Société par Actions Simplifiée au capital de 580 000 EUR
Makati 1211– Manila – Philippines       Immatriculée sous le n° 483 538 369 R.C.S. Bobigny
t:+63 9 07 385 0035                     rating@planetrating.com www.planetrating.com
Microfinance and Social Investments

   Microfinance Institutions as Agents of Social Change


   A Victim of Its Own Success: Growth and Professionalization of
      Microfinance


   The Commercial Drift of Microfinance: From Social Goals to
      Capitalist Principles


   Beyond Good Intentions: Assessing Social Performance in
      Microfinance


   The Road Ahead: Greater Transparency and Accountability in
      Realization of Social Goals
Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments          2
Microfinance Institutions
                                            Agents of Social Change




Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments          3
Microfinance as a Tool for Poverty Alleviation


  Out of the world’s 6.7 billion inhabitants,
   3 billion live on less than 2 USD per day

  80% of the world’s population has no
   access to financial services




  Agent of
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments          4
Originals of Microfinance

  Microfinance has social objectives at its core

   Poverty reduction




  Agent of
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments          5
Originals of Microfinance

  Microfinance has social objectives at its core

   Poverty reduction

   Employment creation




  Agent of
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments          6
Originals of Microfinance

  Microfinance has social objectives at its core

   Poverty reduction

   Employment creation

   Empowerment of marginal groups




  Agent of
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments          7
Originals of Microfinance

  Microfinance has social objectives at its core

   Poverty reduction

   Employment creation

   Empowerment of marginal groups

   Social mission and commitment




  Agent of
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments          8
Building Inclusive Financial Systems

  Microfinance implies building inclusive
   financial systems that serve the poor

  Around the world, over 10,000 MFIs
   provide funding to 150 million active
   clients (3/4 women)

  66.6 million microfinance clients are
   among the poorest, living on less than
   1 USD per day.

  Yet, poor borrowers have proven to be
   astonishingly creditworthy.



  Agent of
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments          9
A High Growth Sector

  MFIs manage a loan portfolio estimated at 30 B USD.

  The potential demand reaches 263 B USD.

  About 500 million microfinance clients have yet to be reached.

  The sector enjoys an annual growth of almost 30%.

  For investors, microfinance is often considered a special asset class of
    socially responsible investment, balancing
     financial return with
     positive social impact.

  Traditionally, microfinance grew with the support of government subsidies,
    donor funding, and grants.
  Agent of
                                  Growth
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments              10
A High Growth Sector
                                                                      Number of MIVs, 2000-2008

 Foreign capital investments in
 microfinance topped 10 B USD
 (2008)

 103 Microfinance Investment
 Vehicles (MIVs) claimed an
 estimated 6.6 B USD in assets
 under management




Source: CGAP 2009 MIV Survey


  Agent of
                                  Growth
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                  11
A High Growth Sector
                                                                  Growth in Assets, MIVs, 2006-2009

 Foreign capital investments in
 microfinance topped 10 B USD
 (2008)

 103 Microfinance Investment
 Vehicles (MIVs) claimed an
 estimated 6.6 B USD in assets
 under management

 MIVs are expected to grow at
 double-digit rates.

Source: CGAP 2009 MIV Survey


  Agent of
                                  Growth
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                  12
A High Growth Sector with Imbalances
                                                            Risk Exposure, % of Microfinance Portfolio
                                                                         MIVs, 2006-2008
  Funding continues to be widely
   available and concentrated in the
   largest 150 MFIs.

  Over 40% of the funding provided
   by MIVs have been allocated to as
   low as five MFIs only.




Source: CGAP 2009 MIV Survey


  Agent of
                                  Growth
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                 13
A High Growth Sector with Imbalances
                                                                   Regional Distribution of Microfinance
                                                                         Portfolio, MIVs, 2006-2008
 Geographic concentration of
  microfinance funds is also
  skewed.

 Africa and Asia, where poverty
  and potential demand for
  microfinance are highest,
  receive less than 20% of foreign
  investments.



Source: CGAP 2009 MIV Survey


  Agent of
                                  Growth
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                    14
From Extensive to Intensive Growth

  Financial sustainability through professionalization is essential for massively
   expanding services.
  A key bottleneck derives from the shortage of strong institutions and
   managers.
  Many MFIs have experienced extensive growth marked by rapid expansion of
   branch networks.
  Professionalization for intensive growth results from
    Productivity gains: economies of scale leading to improved efficiency,
     reduced transaction costs, and overall profitability;
    Innovation: (i) diversified product offerings (e.g. savings, remittance
     services, micro-insurance, and micro-housing and agricultural loans) and (ii)
     expanded delivery mechanisms (e.g. mobile banking); and
    Improved utilization of organizational capacity.

  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                   15
The Commercial Drift of Microfinance

  Microfinance enters the mainstream as a profitable business proposition.

  This commercialization has increased market competition at both the
   wholesale and retail levels, to the general benefit of microfinance lenders
   and borrowers alike.

  The entry of private capital has improved access to diversified sources of
   funding.

  With more funding options and higher volume, MFI managers have enhanced
   their negotiating power and skills to access better financing terms.

  Commercialization is necessary to sustain growth in the sector, to scale up
   outreach, and serve a greater number of financially excluded, low-income
   people.

  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization   Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                               16
The Commercial Drift of Microfinance

  A competitive marketplace tends to reduce costs and increase consumer
   choices.
  The push to place significant amounts of additional capital in a limited pool of
   high-growth MFIs and regions increases the risks of the sector overheating,
   with
    Challenges of managing accelerated growth rates in an increasingly
      competitive microfinance market;
    Uneven management and staffing capacity at MFIs; and
    MIVs taking higher exposure with medium-sized MFIs less experienced with
      commercial borrowing.
  Moreover, this migration towards capitalist principles of profit-maximization
   has increased public scrutiny of the sector.

  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization   Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                               17
Microfinance as Sub-subprime
 Lax lending practices and weak regulatory
 oversight, coupled with overabundant
 funding, can lead to irrational growth.




  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization   Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                               18
Microfinance as Sub-subprime
 Lax lending practices and weak regulatory
 oversight, coupled with overabundant
 funding, can lead to irrational growth.
 Commercial pursuit of profits can result in
 perverse incentives for quantity over quality.




  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization   Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                               19
Microfinance as Sub-subprime
 Lax lending practices and weak regulatory
 oversight, coupled with overabundant
 funding, can lead to irrational growth.
 Commercial pursuit of profits can result in
 perverse incentives for quantity over quality.
 Mainstreaming has allowed some MFIs to stray
 up-market (e.g. consumer, SME, and larger
 loans with extended tenors).




  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization   Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                               20
Microfinance as Sub-subprime
 Lax lending practices and weak regulatory
 oversight, coupled with overabundant
 funding, can lead to irrational growth.
 Commercial pursuit of profits can result in
 perverse incentives for quantity over quality.
 Mainstreaming has allowed some MFIs to stray
 up-market (e.g. consumer, SME, and larger
 loans with extended tenors).
 Rapid growth and lack of transparent pricing
 has led to accusations of predatory lending
 and aggressive collection practices by MFIs.




  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization   Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                               21
Microfinance as Sub-subprime
 Lax lending practices and weak regulatory
 oversight, coupled with overabundant
 funding, can lead to irrational growth.
 Commercial pursuit of profits can result in
 perverse incentives for quantity over quality.
 Mainstreaming has allowed some MFIs to stray
 up-market (e.g. consumer, SME, and larger
 loans with extended tenors).
 Rapid growth and lack of transparent pricing
 has led to accusations of predatory lending
 and aggressive collection practices by MFIs.
 Over-borrowing on top of high interest rates
 can produce a cycle of debt that makes the
 poor worse off.
  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization   Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                               22
The Ugly Side of Microlending

                                                                     The unhappy
                                                                     client


            The bad loan officer 




Photos: Kiva

  Agent of
                                   Growth                     Professionalization   Commercialization
Social Change

  Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                               23
A Victim of Its Own Success

                                                                                        Beyond Good
                                                                                         Intentions

  The success of microfinance has led to more scrutiny of the sector, with
    increasing pressure to substantiate its social claims and business model.
  Microfinance can be over-sold and misleadingly described, with often
    exaggerated, excessive, and unsupported myths of poverty impact.
  With negative media coverage, the industry faces a growing challenge to
    demonstrate objectively that microfinance is a sound tool for aiding economic
    and social development.
  Mere fact of investing in microfinance is no longer sufficient to demonstrate
    that an investor is socially responsible.

  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization   Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                               24
Limited Evidence of Poverty Alleviation

                                                                                        Beyond Good
                                                                                         Intentions

 Many studies on the impact of microfinance have been plagued by
  methodological flaws (e.g. selection bias, lack of control groups, measurement
  of counter-factuals, causal links, descriptive case studies, anecdotal evidence,
  limitations in data collection).
 Rencently, more analytically rigorous studies (e.g. randomized control trials)
  paint a measured picture of microfinance’s impact on the poor.
 There is no scientific evidence to suggest that Microfinance is a
  transformational tool to lift people out of poverty.
 The research findings have been disappointing because the expectations of
  microfinance were unrealistically high.

  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization   Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                               25
Limited Evidence of Poverty Alleviation

                                                                                        Beyond Good
                                                                                         Intentions


  Microfinance has a constructive role to play in the campaign to help the
    world’s poor.

  Its impact is not as large and powerful as some promoters romanticize.

  Nor is its contribution in the struggle against poverty as inconsequential as
    critics dismissively contend.

  In general, it is difficult to conduct reliable, scientific testing on the impact
    of microfinance in a cost-effective way.


  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization   Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                               26
Questioning the Faith

                                                                     Re-evaluation of      Beyond Good
                                                                     Ethical Principals     Intentions

  Is microfinance displacing more effective anti-poverty measures?
  Will the legitimate drive to maximize profits result in neglect/abuse of the
   interest of poor clients?
  What exactly is sustainable growth in microfinance?
  How can the interest of all stakeholders (from borrowers, lenders, third party
   businesses, and investors) be better balanced?
  What lessons can be learned from the pitfalls of sub-prime lending in the US?
  How can industry players ensure that microfinance plays a constructive role in
   alleviating poverty?

  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization      Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                  27
Commitment to Benefit Poor People

                                                                     Re-evaluation of      Beyond Good
                                                                     Ethical Principals     Intentions

  Without commercial foundations, microfinance would struggle to become a
   profitable business needed to survive.
  Yet, without firm ethical principles and a strong commitment to benefit the
   lives of poor people, the sector has no privileged status as a vehicle for
   socially responsible investing.
  There is a growing urgency and moral responsibility to ensure that
   microfinance contributes to solving social issues and not to maximize profits.
  Social investors are demanding evidence of not only financial but also social
   returns on investments.

  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization      Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                  28
Commitment to Benefit Poor People

                                                                     Re-evaluation of          Beyond Good
                                                                     Ethical Principals         Intentions


                            Do                                                                    Social
                                                                          Best-in-class MFIs
                                                                                                  Impact
                           Good

                                                                                                  Social
                    Do Your Best                                            All MFIs
                                                                                               Performance



                                                                        All responsible         Consumer
                    Do No Harm
                                                                     financial institutions     Protection


  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization         Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                      29
Client Protection Principles

                                   Assessing Social                  Re-evaluation of      Beyond Good
                                       Viability                     Ethical Principals     Intentions


  Avoidance of Over-indebtedness

  Transparent Pricing

  Appropriate Collection Practices

  Ethical Staff Behavior

  Mechanisms for Redress of Grievances

  Privacy of Client Data


  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization      Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                  30
Social Performance Management

                                   Assessing Social                  Re-evaluation of      Beyond Good
                                       Viability                     Ethical Principals     Intentions


  Measuring and managing social performance of MFIs help them fulfill their
   mission and increase the impact on target groups.
  The sector has shifted from traditional evaluations (with their focus on end
   results and impact) to assessing the entire process by which impact is created.
  As promoted by the Social Performance Task Force, social performance
   management strives to make microfinance more effective in achieving its
   social mission.
  Effective Performance Management means the continual process of translating
   mission and values into practice.

  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization      Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                  31
Social Performance Management Principles

                                   Assessing Social                  Re-evaluation of      Beyond Good
                                       Viability                     Ethical Principals     Intentions


 MFIs that manage their social performance will deliberately:
  Translate its missions and values into clear, measurable objectives to capture
   intentional social benefits;
  Design and implement systems for social responsibility, including client
   protection;
  Track, understand, and report on whether it is achieving its social objectives;

  Align its business processes to achieve both social and financial objectives;
   and
  Ensure that decision-making considers both social and financial outcomes.
  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization      Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                  32
Contribution of Microfinance


    Social Impact                  Assessing Social                  Re-evaluation of      Beyond Good
                                       Viability                     Ethical Principals     Intentions


 As formal employment opportunities shrink, demand for microcredit grows.
 There is strong evidence that poor people value financial services (credit,
   savings, insurance) as a way to cope with poverty and financial shocks.
 Although claims of raising poor people’s income remain unsubstantiated, many
   microfinance clients tend to use microloans and savings to smooth
   consumption rather than purely to grow their enterprises.
 By working with people in poverty, MFIs have a large capacity to empower
   them to better manage their own financial affairs.


  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization      Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                  33
Influencing the Agenda


    Social Impact                  Assessing Social                  Re-evaluation of         Beyond Good
                                       Viability                     Ethical Principals        Intentions


                                                                           Social Investors

                                                      Social Investors
                                                                                     Social Investors

                                                         Tier 2 MFIs                  Tier 1 MFIs


                     Tier 3 MFIs




  Agent of
                                  Growth                     Professionalization      Commercialization
Social Change

 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                        34
The Road Ahead
          Greater Transparency/Accountability in Realization of Social Goals




Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                35
The Road Ahead for Social Investments in Microfinance

 Recognition of social performance assessment as a completely separate and
  technically valid area of inclusive finance
 Increased social transparency in the microfinance sector

 A shift from extensive to more intensive growth

 Integration of the assessment of social performance into the regular
  management systems of MFIs
 Social performance and management
   No longer viewed as a cost/burden on administrative/operational systems
   An opportunity to develop sound and socially viable institutions

 Assessment of social performance of social investors
   Geographic outreach
   Depth (rural/urban, special social group niches, low/high end segment of
     poverty focus, etc.)
   Product diversity
Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments           36
Thank You

                                     Planet Rating Asia
                                   444 EDSA, 21st Floor
                                   Guadalupe Viejo
                                   Makati 1211, Philippines
                                   Tel: +632 897 7992
                                   Fax: +632 897 7992




                                   James Soukamneuth, Ph.D.
                                   Asia Office Director
                                   jsoukam@planetrating.com




                                   Société par Actions Simplifiée
                                   with authorized capital of 667,000 EUR.
                                   Registration number 483 538 369 RCS Bobigny



Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                  37
Planet Rating
                                The Global Microfinance Rating Agency




Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments          38
Planet Rating: The Global Microfinance Rating Agency

  Created in 1999 and transformed into a private, independent rating firm in 2005, Planet Rating
  has over ten years of experience rating microfinance institutions
  Planet Rating boasts the most extensive global coverage, thanks to a network of 6 offices
  spread over 4 continents

    Paris HQ: covering Eastern Europe

    Lima Office: covering Latin America & the Caribbean

    Dakar Office: covering West & Central Africa

    Nairobi Office: covering East & Southern Africa

    Beirut Office: covering Middle East & North Africa

    Manila Office: covering Asia                              Offices
                                                               Missions




  Qualified & experienced team
    Each senior analyst has conducted at least 12 rating missions on 3 different continents

    Analyst backgrounds: investment banking, management consulting, non-profit, microfinance


  Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                               39
GIRAFE Methodology
 Powerful framework to understand an MFI’s risk profile and evaluate its institutional sustainability

   Created in 1999, it is the most comprehensive and transparent rating methodology

   Certified and accredited by CGAP and the ADA Rating Initiative

   Widely recognized worldwide by investors, donors, regulators and microfinance consultants

   Specifically designed and adapted to microfinance, relevant to suit all types, sizes and stages of
   development of MFIs
   Proven and stable methodology already employed for more than 410 ratings in over 65 countries

   An enhanced GIRAFE methodology was finalized in January 2008 in order to anticipate future
   microfinance rating risks and challenges
                        Rating Domains                                    Weightings

                        G overnance                                          24%
                                                                                       Qualitative
                        I nformation                                         10%        domains
                        R isk                                                10%
                        A ctivities                                          20%
                        F unding and liquidity                                         Quantitative
                                                                             14%         domains
                        E fficiency and                                      22%
                           profitability
 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                         40
A Full Range of GIRAFE-based Rating Products

 I) GIRAFE Institutional Rating

   Comprehensive analysis of the MFI risk profile and organizational performance

   Valuable tool for mature MFIs in search of new financing and greater international visibility


 II) Social Performance Rating

   Evaluation of the MFI’s ability to reach its social mission and objectives

   Identification of strengths and weaknesses of its social performance management system


 III) GIRAFE Interactive Assessment

   Interactive approach to the rating analysis that includes training

   Management and internal communication tool for young MFIs in search of technical assistance and donor funding


 IV) GIRAFE Training Module

   Theoretical and practical training with case studies over the course of 2-3 days

   Flexible content and modules suitable for all kinds of participants, regardless of prior knowledge of microfinance



 Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                              41
Large experience in Latin America

                                                     Guatemala              Dominican Republic
Mexico
                                                      FUNDAP                ECLOF
 11 MFIs: ADMIC, Caja
  Cresciencio Cruz, CONSERVA,
                                                                            Haïti
  Despeno, Durango,
  Empredamos Juntos,                                                         COD/MEH
  FOCRECE, PEN, Santa Fe de
  Guanajuato, Semisol,                                                                       Brazil
  Unicreich
                                                                                              17 MFIs: Banco da Familia,
                                                                                               BluSol Brésil, Casa do
Nicaragua                                                                                      Microcredito,CEADe BRAZIL,
 3 MFIs: 20 de Abril, FODEM,                                                                  CEAPE / MA, CEAPE / PB,
  FUNDENUSE                                                                                    CEAPE / PE, CEAPE / PI,
                                                                                               CEAPE / RN, CEAPE / SE,
                                                                                               CEAPE PI, Credisol, CRESOL,
Ecuador                                                                                        PortoSol, RioCred,
 1 MFI: Fundamic                                                                              SOCIALCRED, VivaCred
                                                                                              20 ratings
Peru
 11 MFIs: CAC Santa Maria de                                                           Bolivia
  la Magdalena, COOPAC San                                                              10 MFIs: ANED, CIDRE,
  Martín de Porres, COOPAC                                                               CRECER, Crédito Amigo,
  Tochache, Epydme                                                                       DIACONIA, Eco futuro,
  Alternativa, Prisma, Finca,          Chile                                             FADES, FONDECO,
  FONDESURCO, GCOD,                                                                      FUBODE, IMPRO
                                        1 Bank: Banco del
  Arariwa, Caritas Felices
                                         Desarrollo                                      14 ratings
 15 ratings

   Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                                42
Excellent track record in the MENA region




                                                                                      Jordan
 Morocco                                                                               3 MFIs: AMC, JMCC, MFW

  9 MFIs: Al Amana, Al                                                                6 ratings
   Karama, Amos, AMSSF/
   MC, FCAMC, FONDEP,
   INMAA, Ismailia,                                                                   Palestine
   Zakoura                                                                             8 MFIs: ACAD, Alrafah,
  20 ratings                                                                           Asala, FATEN, PDF, PARC-
                                                                                        SCA, UNRWA, YMCA-SED
                                                                                       8 ratings




 Tunisia                                Egypt                            Yemen
  1 MFI: Enda                           7 MFIs: ABA, Al Tadamun,        1 MFI: Hodeidah
                                          ASBA, DBACD, Lead                Microfinance Program
  2 ratings                              Foundation, SBACD, FMF
                                                                          1 rating
                                         10 ratings




Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                               43
The Leading Rating Agency in Sub-Saharan Africa

 Mali: Kafo Jiginew, FCRMD, Jemeni, Kondo           Niger: ASUSU, MCPEC,            Ethiopia: OCSSCO, PEACE,
 Jigima, Misélini, Niako, CVECA ON, Nyeta           UMEC, MECREF, Albarka           Buusaa Gonofaa, SFPI, Eshet,
 Musow, Piyeli, Soro Yriwaso, PASECA                SA, Yarda Zinder, Yarda         Wasasa, AVFS, Harbu,
 Kayes, RMCR, Nyesigiso                             Madaoua                         Metemamen

                                                                                    Kenya: EBS, SMEP, ECLOF,
 Senegal: UMECU,
                                                                                    SISDO, Yehu, PAWDEP, AAR,
 PAMECAS, ACEP, Delta,                                                              Ebony Foundation
 AFER, Caurie, Tostan
                                                                                    Uganda: UML, HOFOKAM, SMS,
 Burkina: RCPB, UCEC-                                                               FOCCAS, Ugafode, Terudet,
 Z, URCCOM, URCBAM                                                                  SAO-MFI and 10 SACCOs

 Ghana: SAT, APED,                                                                  Rwanda: COOPEDU,
 CRAN, ECLOF Ghana                                                                  Duterimbere, ACB, CAF Isonga
 and 9 rural banks;
                                                                                    Madagascar: Otiv de la Sava,
 Benin: Vital Finance, PAPME, PADME,                                                Vola Mahasoa
 FINADEV, FICA, FENACREP, Convergence
 2000, CNACFD, CBDIBA, ASSEF                                                        South Africa: Marang, Kuyasa
                                                                                    Fund, NBF, Tiisha


 Tanzania: SELFINA; Mozambique: Socremo Bank, Burundi: COSPEC; Malawi: CUMO; Zambia: CETZAM; Comoros:
 Sanduk; Central Africa Republic: CMCA, Ivory Coast: CICA, Chad: UCEC Pala, Gambia: GAWFA; Guinea Conakry: PRIDE,
 CRG; Cameroon: CDM, ACEP, SAILD, COMECI, SOFINA; Togo: WAGES, TIMPAC, SEBADERS, UMECTO;



Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                             44
Diversified experience in Eastern Europe and Central Asia

Bosnia Herzegovina             Ukraine                                                          Russia
 10 MFIs: Mikrofin,            HOPE                                                            5 MFIs: FFECCC, RWMN,
  Benefit, EKI, LOK micro,                                                                        VRFSBS, Doveriye,
  Mi-Bospo, Partner,                                                                              Narodnyi
  Prizma, Sunrise, Women
                                                                                                 7 ratings
  for Women, Sinergija
  Plus
 23 ratings


Serbia
 Montenegro
 AgroInvest
 3 ratings
                                                                                                 Mongolia
                                                                                                  2 Banks: Khan Bank,
Bulgaria                                                                                           Xac Bank
 Easy Credit                                                                                     1 MFI: VisionFund Mongolia
Kosovo                                                                                          Tadjikistan
 KEP                                                                                            1 Bank: Bank Eskhata
                                                                           Azerbaijan
Moldova                Georgia                Armenia                       AzerdemyriolBank
 MicroInvest           Constanta                                           AzeriStar
                                               3 MFIs: Aregak, MDF-
 3 ratings             2 ratings              Kamurj, Nor Horizon         3 ratings

  Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                                   45
Growing experience in Asia

                         Mongolia
                                                                                   China
                          2 Banks: Khan Bank, Xac
                           Bank                                                     Industry diagnostic
                          1 MFI: VisionFund Mongolia                               Training
                                                                                    Interactive Assessment
                                                                                     (Harbin Bank)

  Afghanistan
   1 MFI: Sunduq                                                                  Vietnam
                                                                                    3 MFIs: CEP, TYM Fund,
                                                                                     Binh Minh
  India                                                                             5 ratings
   3 MFIs: ASA Grama
    Vidiyal, LEAD, SWC




  Cambodia
   5 MFIs: CREDIT, Vision                      Indonesia                      Philippines
    Fund Cambodia, TPC,
                                                 Ratings of 5 Cooperatives,    8 MFIs: CARD, LifeBank,
    Seilanithih, CCSF
                                                  including KOMIDA               PMPC, CEVI, GM Bank,
   9 ratings                                                                    ECLOF, HSPFI, SEDP
                                                  Workshop

Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                       46
Contacts


  Global Headquarters                                              Middle East & North Africa
13 rue Dieumegard                                                 Picadilly Bldg #407
93400 Saint-Ouen Paris – France                                   Hamra Street
Tel: +33 1 4921 2630                                              Beirut – Lebanon

Fax: +33 1 4921 2627                                              Tel: +961 3 11 96 81


  Latin America                                                    West Africa & Central Africa

Francisco de Paula Ugarriza 813 – Oficina 301                     Boulevard Djily Mbaye
Miraflores, Lima 18 – Peru                                        Immeuble FADH, 14th floor

Tel: +51 1 242 4597                                               BP 5695 Dakar – Senegal
Fax: +51 1 242 4597                                               Tel/Fax: +221 33 821 79 39


  Asia                                                             East Africa & Southern Africa

444 EDSA 21st floor, Guadalupe Viejo                              Shelter Afrique House – Mamlaka Road
1211 Makati, Manila – Philippines                                 PO Box 16658, 00100 Nairobi – Kenya

Tel/Fax: +632 897 7992                                  Tel: +254 20 271 42 20
                          www.planetrating.com - rating@planetrating.com

Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments                                          47

Weitere ähnliche Inhalte

Was ist angesagt?

Kiva Due Diligence Template
Kiva Due Diligence TemplateKiva Due Diligence Template
Kiva Due Diligence TemplatePremal Shah
 
Financing for Development - Financing MSMEs for Economic Growth and Development
Financing for Development - Financing MSMEs for Economic Growth and DevelopmentFinancing for Development - Financing MSMEs for Economic Growth and Development
Financing for Development - Financing MSMEs for Economic Growth and DevelopmentR. M
 
SMDP Microfinance Refresher MODULE 1
SMDP Microfinance Refresher MODULE 1SMDP Microfinance Refresher MODULE 1
SMDP Microfinance Refresher MODULE 1SMDP-UNH
 
II SEM M.COM MICRO FINANCE MODULE 3
II SEM M.COM MICRO FINANCE MODULE 3II SEM M.COM MICRO FINANCE MODULE 3
II SEM M.COM MICRO FINANCE MODULE 3Drchitra Devi
 
Community Development Venture Capital Funds
Community Development Venture Capital FundsCommunity Development Venture Capital Funds
Community Development Venture Capital FundsNapoleon C. Birch Jr.
 
Ppt on micro finance
Ppt on micro financePpt on micro finance
Ppt on micro financeriya06
 
Micro finance and economic development
Micro finance and economic developmentMicro finance and economic development
Micro finance and economic developmenttutor2u
 
Gender in Crowdfunding (Based on Kickstarter Data)
Gender in Crowdfunding (Based on Kickstarter Data)Gender in Crowdfunding (Based on Kickstarter Data)
Gender in Crowdfunding (Based on Kickstarter Data)Crowdfund Productions, LLC
 
Visa Acquirer-Best-Practices Brochure-ENG
Visa Acquirer-Best-Practices Brochure-ENGVisa Acquirer-Best-Practices Brochure-ENG
Visa Acquirer-Best-Practices Brochure-ENGAlexandre Peyser
 
THE IMPACT INVESTOR’S HANDBOOK Lessons from the World of Microfinance
THE IMPACT INVESTOR’S  HANDBOOK Lessons from the World of MicrofinanceTHE IMPACT INVESTOR’S  HANDBOOK Lessons from the World of Microfinance
THE IMPACT INVESTOR’S HANDBOOK Lessons from the World of MicrofinanceIDIS
 
p2p microfinance presentation before Kiva
p2p microfinance presentation before Kivap2p microfinance presentation before Kiva
p2p microfinance presentation before Kivaguestc0a771
 
Micro finance and enterprenurship
Micro finance and enterprenurshipMicro finance and enterprenurship
Micro finance and enterprenurshipAk Maheshwari
 
Micro finance - an introduction
Micro finance - an introductionMicro finance - an introduction
Micro finance - an introductionSuman Bhattarai
 
Crowdfunding for Impact, July 2016
Crowdfunding for Impact, July 2016Crowdfunding for Impact, July 2016
Crowdfunding for Impact, July 2016Kathleen Holmlund
 
Introduction to Crowd funding
Introduction to Crowd funding  Introduction to Crowd funding
Introduction to Crowd funding Isru
 

Was ist angesagt? (20)

Kiva Due Diligence Template
Kiva Due Diligence TemplateKiva Due Diligence Template
Kiva Due Diligence Template
 
MicrofinancePaper
MicrofinancePaperMicrofinancePaper
MicrofinancePaper
 
Financing for Development - Financing MSMEs for Economic Growth and Development
Financing for Development - Financing MSMEs for Economic Growth and DevelopmentFinancing for Development - Financing MSMEs for Economic Growth and Development
Financing for Development - Financing MSMEs for Economic Growth and Development
 
SMDP Microfinance Refresher MODULE 1
SMDP Microfinance Refresher MODULE 1SMDP Microfinance Refresher MODULE 1
SMDP Microfinance Refresher MODULE 1
 
II SEM M.COM MICRO FINANCE MODULE 3
II SEM M.COM MICRO FINANCE MODULE 3II SEM M.COM MICRO FINANCE MODULE 3
II SEM M.COM MICRO FINANCE MODULE 3
 
Community Development Venture Capital Funds
Community Development Venture Capital FundsCommunity Development Venture Capital Funds
Community Development Venture Capital Funds
 
Ppt on micro finance
Ppt on micro financePpt on micro finance
Ppt on micro finance
 
Micro finance and economic development
Micro finance and economic developmentMicro finance and economic development
Micro finance and economic development
 
micro finance
micro financemicro finance
micro finance
 
Gender in Crowdfunding (Based on Kickstarter Data)
Gender in Crowdfunding (Based on Kickstarter Data)Gender in Crowdfunding (Based on Kickstarter Data)
Gender in Crowdfunding (Based on Kickstarter Data)
 
Visa Acquirer-Best-Practices Brochure-ENG
Visa Acquirer-Best-Practices Brochure-ENGVisa Acquirer-Best-Practices Brochure-ENG
Visa Acquirer-Best-Practices Brochure-ENG
 
THE IMPACT INVESTOR’S HANDBOOK Lessons from the World of Microfinance
THE IMPACT INVESTOR’S  HANDBOOK Lessons from the World of MicrofinanceTHE IMPACT INVESTOR’S  HANDBOOK Lessons from the World of Microfinance
THE IMPACT INVESTOR’S HANDBOOK Lessons from the World of Microfinance
 
p2p microfinance presentation before Kiva
p2p microfinance presentation before Kivap2p microfinance presentation before Kiva
p2p microfinance presentation before Kiva
 
Micro finance and enterprenurship
Micro finance and enterprenurshipMicro finance and enterprenurship
Micro finance and enterprenurship
 
Micro finance - an introduction
Micro finance - an introductionMicro finance - an introduction
Micro finance - an introduction
 
Crowdfunding for Impact, July 2016
Crowdfunding for Impact, July 2016Crowdfunding for Impact, July 2016
Crowdfunding for Impact, July 2016
 
Introduction to Crowd funding
Introduction to Crowd funding  Introduction to Crowd funding
Introduction to Crowd funding
 
VPS Millennials LAC WP
VPS Millennials LAC WPVPS Millennials LAC WP
VPS Millennials LAC WP
 
Corporate community investment and development- Africa 2013
Corporate community investment and development- Africa 2013Corporate community investment and development- Africa 2013
Corporate community investment and development- Africa 2013
 
Micro finance
Micro financeMicro finance
Micro finance
 

Ähnlich wie Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments

The Future of Microfinance in Africa SAM 2015 - Plenary Day 9
The Future of Microfinance in Africa SAM 2015 - Plenary Day 9The Future of Microfinance in Africa SAM 2015 - Plenary Day 9
The Future of Microfinance in Africa SAM 2015 - Plenary Day 9School of African Microfinance
 
Microfinance Market.docx
Microfinance Market.docxMicrofinance Market.docx
Microfinance Market.docxNehaShaikh73
 
Trends in the microfinance ecosystem
Trends in the microfinance ecosystemTrends in the microfinance ecosystem
Trends in the microfinance ecosystemTulasi Ram
 
An Industry in Crisis, Facing Reality SAM 2015 - Plenary Session Day 5
An Industry in Crisis, Facing Reality SAM 2015 - Plenary Session Day 5An Industry in Crisis, Facing Reality SAM 2015 - Plenary Session Day 5
An Industry in Crisis, Facing Reality SAM 2015 - Plenary Session Day 5School of African Microfinance
 
Microfinance An Introduction
Microfinance An IntroductionMicrofinance An Introduction
Microfinance An IntroductionKabare Piyush
 
The Impact of Microcredit on the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) ...
The Impact of Microcredit on the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) ...The Impact of Microcredit on the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) ...
The Impact of Microcredit on the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) ...Business, Management and Economics Research
 
Harnessing the Fintech Revolution - IIC Oliver Wyman
Harnessing the Fintech Revolution - IIC Oliver WymanHarnessing the Fintech Revolution - IIC Oliver Wyman
Harnessing the Fintech Revolution - IIC Oliver WymanGreg Da Re
 
B241 - Microfinance Issues and Breakthroughs Class Review
B241 - Microfinance Issues and Breakthroughs Class ReviewB241 - Microfinance Issues and Breakthroughs Class Review
B241 - Microfinance Issues and Breakthroughs Class Reviewpalimpsestsoul
 
Pim engels - The Trade-off between Financial and Social Performance
Pim engels - The Trade-off between Financial and Social PerformancePim engels - The Trade-off between Financial and Social Performance
Pim engels - The Trade-off between Financial and Social Performancepimengels
 
Dfid micfac presentation 29 sept
Dfid   micfac presentation 29 septDfid   micfac presentation 29 sept
Dfid micfac presentation 29 septcarolinewood79
 
What is MICFAC?
What is MICFAC?What is MICFAC?
What is MICFAC?DFID
 
Microfinance
MicrofinanceMicrofinance
Microfinancearsal87
 
Financing the Bottom of the Pyramid By Saurabh Bhat
Financing the Bottom of the Pyramid By Saurabh BhatFinancing the Bottom of the Pyramid By Saurabh Bhat
Financing the Bottom of the Pyramid By Saurabh Bhatsmeniwas
 
The future of microfinance in india
The future of microfinance in indiaThe future of microfinance in india
The future of microfinance in indiasatrujeetsahoo
 
Financing the Microfinanciers, How MFIs are sourcing capital -- joint BlueOrc...
Financing the Microfinanciers, How MFIs are sourcing capital -- joint BlueOrc...Financing the Microfinanciers, How MFIs are sourcing capital -- joint BlueOrc...
Financing the Microfinanciers, How MFIs are sourcing capital -- joint BlueOrc...svmn
 
Micro finance nikita 1
Micro finance  nikita 1Micro finance  nikita 1
Micro finance nikita 1vinayaka_1987
 
Constraints to the Development of Microfinance Sector in Pakistan
Constraints to the Development of Microfinance Sector in PakistanConstraints to the Development of Microfinance Sector in Pakistan
Constraints to the Development of Microfinance Sector in PakistanAyesha Majid
 

Ähnlich wie Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments (20)

The Future of Microfinance in Africa SAM 2015 - Plenary Day 9
The Future of Microfinance in Africa SAM 2015 - Plenary Day 9The Future of Microfinance in Africa SAM 2015 - Plenary Day 9
The Future of Microfinance in Africa SAM 2015 - Plenary Day 9
 
Microfinance Market.docx
Microfinance Market.docxMicrofinance Market.docx
Microfinance Market.docx
 
Trends in the microfinance ecosystem
Trends in the microfinance ecosystemTrends in the microfinance ecosystem
Trends in the microfinance ecosystem
 
An Industry in Crisis, Facing Reality SAM 2015 - Plenary Session Day 5
An Industry in Crisis, Facing Reality SAM 2015 - Plenary Session Day 5An Industry in Crisis, Facing Reality SAM 2015 - Plenary Session Day 5
An Industry in Crisis, Facing Reality SAM 2015 - Plenary Session Day 5
 
Microfinance and the Global Financial Crisis
Microfinance and the Global Financial CrisisMicrofinance and the Global Financial Crisis
Microfinance and the Global Financial Crisis
 
Microfinance An Introduction
Microfinance An IntroductionMicrofinance An Introduction
Microfinance An Introduction
 
The Impact of Microcredit on the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) ...
The Impact of Microcredit on the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) ...The Impact of Microcredit on the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) ...
The Impact of Microcredit on the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) ...
 
microfinance
microfinancemicrofinance
microfinance
 
Harnessing the Fintech Revolution - IIC Oliver Wyman
Harnessing the Fintech Revolution - IIC Oliver WymanHarnessing the Fintech Revolution - IIC Oliver Wyman
Harnessing the Fintech Revolution - IIC Oliver Wyman
 
B241 - Microfinance Issues and Breakthroughs Class Review
B241 - Microfinance Issues and Breakthroughs Class ReviewB241 - Microfinance Issues and Breakthroughs Class Review
B241 - Microfinance Issues and Breakthroughs Class Review
 
Pim engels - The Trade-off between Financial and Social Performance
Pim engels - The Trade-off between Financial and Social PerformancePim engels - The Trade-off between Financial and Social Performance
Pim engels - The Trade-off between Financial and Social Performance
 
Dfid micfac presentation 29 sept
Dfid   micfac presentation 29 septDfid   micfac presentation 29 sept
Dfid micfac presentation 29 sept
 
What is MICFAC?
What is MICFAC?What is MICFAC?
What is MICFAC?
 
Microfinance
MicrofinanceMicrofinance
Microfinance
 
Financing the Bottom of the Pyramid By Saurabh Bhat
Financing the Bottom of the Pyramid By Saurabh BhatFinancing the Bottom of the Pyramid By Saurabh Bhat
Financing the Bottom of the Pyramid By Saurabh Bhat
 
The future of microfinance in india
The future of microfinance in indiaThe future of microfinance in india
The future of microfinance in india
 
Microfinance
MicrofinanceMicrofinance
Microfinance
 
Financing the Microfinanciers, How MFIs are sourcing capital -- joint BlueOrc...
Financing the Microfinanciers, How MFIs are sourcing capital -- joint BlueOrc...Financing the Microfinanciers, How MFIs are sourcing capital -- joint BlueOrc...
Financing the Microfinanciers, How MFIs are sourcing capital -- joint BlueOrc...
 
Micro finance nikita 1
Micro finance  nikita 1Micro finance  nikita 1
Micro finance nikita 1
 
Constraints to the Development of Microfinance Sector in Pakistan
Constraints to the Development of Microfinance Sector in PakistanConstraints to the Development of Microfinance Sector in Pakistan
Constraints to the Development of Microfinance Sector in Pakistan
 

Mehr von MABSIV

RBAP-MABS Moving Forward
RBAP-MABS Moving ForwardRBAP-MABS Moving Forward
RBAP-MABS Moving ForwardMABSIV
 
USING NEW CHANNELS TO EXPAND MICROFINANCE SEVICES
USING NEW CHANNELS TO EXPAND MICROFINANCE SEVICESUSING NEW CHANNELS TO EXPAND MICROFINANCE SEVICES
USING NEW CHANNELS TO EXPAND MICROFINANCE SEVICESMABSIV
 
The SMART Islands Activation Program Empowerment through Mobile Banking
The SMART Islands Activation Program Empowerment through Mobile BankingThe SMART Islands Activation Program Empowerment through Mobile Banking
The SMART Islands Activation Program Empowerment through Mobile BankingMABSIV
 
Preliminary Evaluation of Consumer Education Tools for Mobile Phone Banking: ...
Preliminary Evaluation of Consumer Education Tools for Mobile Phone Banking: ...Preliminary Evaluation of Consumer Education Tools for Mobile Phone Banking: ...
Preliminary Evaluation of Consumer Education Tools for Mobile Phone Banking: ...MABSIV
 
MOBILE COMMERCE INNOVATIONS: NEW IDEAS & RETURNS
MOBILE COMMERCE INNOVATIONS: NEW IDEAS & RETURNSMOBILE COMMERCE INNOVATIONS: NEW IDEAS & RETURNS
MOBILE COMMERCE INNOVATIONS: NEW IDEAS & RETURNSMABSIV
 
Lessons in Microinsurance Business Expansion
Lessons in Microinsurance Business ExpansionLessons in Microinsurance Business Expansion
Lessons in Microinsurance Business ExpansionMABSIV
 
Successful Partnerships in Microinsurance
Successful Partnerships in MicroinsuranceSuccessful Partnerships in Microinsurance
Successful Partnerships in MicroinsuranceMABSIV
 
The Katipunan Bank Experience
The Katipunan Bank ExperienceThe Katipunan Bank Experience
The Katipunan Bank ExperienceMABSIV
 
Microinsurance: Guarding the poor from falling
Microinsurance: Guarding the poor from fallingMicroinsurance: Guarding the poor from falling
Microinsurance: Guarding the poor from fallingMABSIV
 
Beyond SMS: Using Social Networks to Reach a Broader Market
Beyond SMS: Using Social Networks to Reach a Broader MarketBeyond SMS: Using Social Networks to Reach a Broader Market
Beyond SMS: Using Social Networks to Reach a Broader MarketMABSIV
 
The Microfinance Data Sharing System (MiDAS)
The Microfinance Data Sharing System (MiDAS)The Microfinance Data Sharing System (MiDAS)
The Microfinance Data Sharing System (MiDAS)MABSIV
 
Using the Credit Bureau: Experience from the Field
Using the Credit Bureau: Experience from the FieldUsing the Credit Bureau: Experience from the Field
Using the Credit Bureau: Experience from the FieldMABSIV
 
Listening to Data
Listening to DataListening to Data
Listening to DataMABSIV
 
Results of the Study on Multiple Lending and the Challenges Faced by Banks
Results of the Study on Multiple Lending and the Challenges Faced by BanksResults of the Study on Multiple Lending and the Challenges Faced by Banks
Results of the Study on Multiple Lending and the Challenges Faced by BanksMABSIV
 
“SCORECARD” Incentive Remuneration System for Microfinance
“SCORECARD” Incentive Remuneration System for Microfinance“SCORECARD” Incentive Remuneration System for Microfinance
“SCORECARD” Incentive Remuneration System for MicrofinanceMABSIV
 
Measuring Performance through the EAGLE Score Card
Measuring Performance through the EAGLE Score CardMeasuring Performance through the EAGLE Score Card
Measuring Performance through the EAGLE Score CardMABSIV
 
Price Transparency and Microfinance Related Regulations
Price Transparency and Microfinance Related RegulationsPrice Transparency and Microfinance Related Regulations
Price Transparency and Microfinance Related RegulationsMABSIV
 
Using data to understand your Rural Bank
Using data to understand your Rural BankUsing data to understand your Rural Bank
Using data to understand your Rural BankMABSIV
 
Mobile Commerce Summit Presentation
Mobile Commerce Summit PresentationMobile Commerce Summit Presentation
Mobile Commerce Summit PresentationMABSIV
 
Current & future trends for rural banks to consider in providing greater acc...
Current & future trends  for rural banks to consider in providing greater acc...Current & future trends  for rural banks to consider in providing greater acc...
Current & future trends for rural banks to consider in providing greater acc...MABSIV
 

Mehr von MABSIV (20)

RBAP-MABS Moving Forward
RBAP-MABS Moving ForwardRBAP-MABS Moving Forward
RBAP-MABS Moving Forward
 
USING NEW CHANNELS TO EXPAND MICROFINANCE SEVICES
USING NEW CHANNELS TO EXPAND MICROFINANCE SEVICESUSING NEW CHANNELS TO EXPAND MICROFINANCE SEVICES
USING NEW CHANNELS TO EXPAND MICROFINANCE SEVICES
 
The SMART Islands Activation Program Empowerment through Mobile Banking
The SMART Islands Activation Program Empowerment through Mobile BankingThe SMART Islands Activation Program Empowerment through Mobile Banking
The SMART Islands Activation Program Empowerment through Mobile Banking
 
Preliminary Evaluation of Consumer Education Tools for Mobile Phone Banking: ...
Preliminary Evaluation of Consumer Education Tools for Mobile Phone Banking: ...Preliminary Evaluation of Consumer Education Tools for Mobile Phone Banking: ...
Preliminary Evaluation of Consumer Education Tools for Mobile Phone Banking: ...
 
MOBILE COMMERCE INNOVATIONS: NEW IDEAS & RETURNS
MOBILE COMMERCE INNOVATIONS: NEW IDEAS & RETURNSMOBILE COMMERCE INNOVATIONS: NEW IDEAS & RETURNS
MOBILE COMMERCE INNOVATIONS: NEW IDEAS & RETURNS
 
Lessons in Microinsurance Business Expansion
Lessons in Microinsurance Business ExpansionLessons in Microinsurance Business Expansion
Lessons in Microinsurance Business Expansion
 
Successful Partnerships in Microinsurance
Successful Partnerships in MicroinsuranceSuccessful Partnerships in Microinsurance
Successful Partnerships in Microinsurance
 
The Katipunan Bank Experience
The Katipunan Bank ExperienceThe Katipunan Bank Experience
The Katipunan Bank Experience
 
Microinsurance: Guarding the poor from falling
Microinsurance: Guarding the poor from fallingMicroinsurance: Guarding the poor from falling
Microinsurance: Guarding the poor from falling
 
Beyond SMS: Using Social Networks to Reach a Broader Market
Beyond SMS: Using Social Networks to Reach a Broader MarketBeyond SMS: Using Social Networks to Reach a Broader Market
Beyond SMS: Using Social Networks to Reach a Broader Market
 
The Microfinance Data Sharing System (MiDAS)
The Microfinance Data Sharing System (MiDAS)The Microfinance Data Sharing System (MiDAS)
The Microfinance Data Sharing System (MiDAS)
 
Using the Credit Bureau: Experience from the Field
Using the Credit Bureau: Experience from the FieldUsing the Credit Bureau: Experience from the Field
Using the Credit Bureau: Experience from the Field
 
Listening to Data
Listening to DataListening to Data
Listening to Data
 
Results of the Study on Multiple Lending and the Challenges Faced by Banks
Results of the Study on Multiple Lending and the Challenges Faced by BanksResults of the Study on Multiple Lending and the Challenges Faced by Banks
Results of the Study on Multiple Lending and the Challenges Faced by Banks
 
“SCORECARD” Incentive Remuneration System for Microfinance
“SCORECARD” Incentive Remuneration System for Microfinance“SCORECARD” Incentive Remuneration System for Microfinance
“SCORECARD” Incentive Remuneration System for Microfinance
 
Measuring Performance through the EAGLE Score Card
Measuring Performance through the EAGLE Score CardMeasuring Performance through the EAGLE Score Card
Measuring Performance through the EAGLE Score Card
 
Price Transparency and Microfinance Related Regulations
Price Transparency and Microfinance Related RegulationsPrice Transparency and Microfinance Related Regulations
Price Transparency and Microfinance Related Regulations
 
Using data to understand your Rural Bank
Using data to understand your Rural BankUsing data to understand your Rural Bank
Using data to understand your Rural Bank
 
Mobile Commerce Summit Presentation
Mobile Commerce Summit PresentationMobile Commerce Summit Presentation
Mobile Commerce Summit Presentation
 
Current & future trends for rural banks to consider in providing greater acc...
Current & future trends  for rural banks to consider in providing greater acc...Current & future trends  for rural banks to consider in providing greater acc...
Current & future trends for rural banks to consider in providing greater acc...
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen

Driving Business Impact for PMs with Jon Harmer
Driving Business Impact for PMs with Jon HarmerDriving Business Impact for PMs with Jon Harmer
Driving Business Impact for PMs with Jon HarmerAggregage
 
Cyber Security Training in Office Environment
Cyber Security Training in Office EnvironmentCyber Security Training in Office Environment
Cyber Security Training in Office Environmentelijahj01012
 
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptxAppkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptxappkodes
 
Planetary and Vedic Yagyas Bring Positive Impacts in Life
Planetary and Vedic Yagyas Bring Positive Impacts in LifePlanetary and Vedic Yagyas Bring Positive Impacts in Life
Planetary and Vedic Yagyas Bring Positive Impacts in LifeBhavana Pujan Kendra
 
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024Adnet Communications
 
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptxGo for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptxRakhi Bazaar
 
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...Americas Got Grants
 
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exportersEUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exportersPeter Horsten
 
Environmental Impact Of Rotary Screw Compressors
Environmental Impact Of Rotary Screw CompressorsEnvironmental Impact Of Rotary Screw Compressors
Environmental Impact Of Rotary Screw Compressorselgieurope
 
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdfShaun Heinrichs
 
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdf
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdfGUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdf
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdfDanny Diep To
 
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdfShaun Heinrichs
 
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptx
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptxThe-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptx
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptxmbikashkanyari
 
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDF
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDFGuide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDF
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDFChandresh Chudasama
 
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh JiPsychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Jiastral oracle
 
Fordham -How effective decision-making is within the IT department - Analysis...
Fordham -How effective decision-making is within the IT department - Analysis...Fordham -How effective decision-making is within the IT department - Analysis...
Fordham -How effective decision-making is within the IT department - Analysis...Peter Ward
 
20220816-EthicsGrade_Scorecard-JP_Morgan_Chase-Q2-63_57.pdf
20220816-EthicsGrade_Scorecard-JP_Morgan_Chase-Q2-63_57.pdf20220816-EthicsGrade_Scorecard-JP_Morgan_Chase-Q2-63_57.pdf
20220816-EthicsGrade_Scorecard-JP_Morgan_Chase-Q2-63_57.pdfChris Skinner
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: Xpanceo's $40M Seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Xpanceo's $40M Seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: Xpanceo's $40M Seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Xpanceo's $40M Seed deckHajeJanKamps
 
WSMM Media and Entertainment Feb_March_Final.pdf
WSMM Media and Entertainment Feb_March_Final.pdfWSMM Media and Entertainment Feb_March_Final.pdf
WSMM Media and Entertainment Feb_March_Final.pdfJamesConcepcion7
 
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdf
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdfWSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdf
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdfJamesConcepcion7
 

Kürzlich hochgeladen (20)

Driving Business Impact for PMs with Jon Harmer
Driving Business Impact for PMs with Jon HarmerDriving Business Impact for PMs with Jon Harmer
Driving Business Impact for PMs with Jon Harmer
 
Cyber Security Training in Office Environment
Cyber Security Training in Office EnvironmentCyber Security Training in Office Environment
Cyber Security Training in Office Environment
 
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptxAppkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
 
Planetary and Vedic Yagyas Bring Positive Impacts in Life
Planetary and Vedic Yagyas Bring Positive Impacts in LifePlanetary and Vedic Yagyas Bring Positive Impacts in Life
Planetary and Vedic Yagyas Bring Positive Impacts in Life
 
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
 
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptxGo for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
 
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...
 
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exportersEUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
 
Environmental Impact Of Rotary Screw Compressors
Environmental Impact Of Rotary Screw CompressorsEnvironmental Impact Of Rotary Screw Compressors
Environmental Impact Of Rotary Screw Compressors
 
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
 
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdf
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdfGUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdf
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdf
 
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
 
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptx
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptxThe-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptx
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptx
 
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDF
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDFGuide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDF
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDF
 
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh JiPsychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
 
Fordham -How effective decision-making is within the IT department - Analysis...
Fordham -How effective decision-making is within the IT department - Analysis...Fordham -How effective decision-making is within the IT department - Analysis...
Fordham -How effective decision-making is within the IT department - Analysis...
 
20220816-EthicsGrade_Scorecard-JP_Morgan_Chase-Q2-63_57.pdf
20220816-EthicsGrade_Scorecard-JP_Morgan_Chase-Q2-63_57.pdf20220816-EthicsGrade_Scorecard-JP_Morgan_Chase-Q2-63_57.pdf
20220816-EthicsGrade_Scorecard-JP_Morgan_Chase-Q2-63_57.pdf
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: Xpanceo's $40M Seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Xpanceo's $40M Seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: Xpanceo's $40M Seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Xpanceo's $40M Seed deck
 
WSMM Media and Entertainment Feb_March_Final.pdf
WSMM Media and Entertainment Feb_March_Final.pdfWSMM Media and Entertainment Feb_March_Final.pdf
WSMM Media and Entertainment Feb_March_Final.pdf
 
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdf
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdfWSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdf
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdf
 

Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments

  • 1. RBAP-MABS National Roundtable Conference Evolution of the Microfinance Investment Landscape and Reasons behind the Growth of Social Investments A Broad Overview By James Soukamneuth, Ph.D. Asia Office Director, Planet Rating jsoukam@planetrating.com Hyatt Hotel, Malate Manila June 2, 2010 Planet Rating, c/o James Soukamneuth Accredited by ADA Rating Initiative 444 EDSA, 21st floor– Guadalupe Viejo Société par Actions Simplifiée au capital de 580 000 EUR Makati 1211– Manila – Philippines Immatriculée sous le n° 483 538 369 R.C.S. Bobigny t:+63 9 07 385 0035 rating@planetrating.com www.planetrating.com
  • 2. Microfinance and Social Investments   Microfinance Institutions as Agents of Social Change   A Victim of Its Own Success: Growth and Professionalization of Microfinance   The Commercial Drift of Microfinance: From Social Goals to Capitalist Principles   Beyond Good Intentions: Assessing Social Performance in Microfinance   The Road Ahead: Greater Transparency and Accountability in Realization of Social Goals Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      2
  • 3. Microfinance Institutions Agents of Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      3
  • 4. Microfinance as a Tool for Poverty Alleviation  Out of the world’s 6.7 billion inhabitants, 3 billion live on less than 2 USD per day  80% of the world’s population has no access to financial services Agent of Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      4
  • 5. Originals of Microfinance  Microfinance has social objectives at its core Poverty reduction Agent of Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      5
  • 6. Originals of Microfinance  Microfinance has social objectives at its core Poverty reduction Employment creation Agent of Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      6
  • 7. Originals of Microfinance  Microfinance has social objectives at its core Poverty reduction Employment creation Empowerment of marginal groups Agent of Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      7
  • 8. Originals of Microfinance  Microfinance has social objectives at its core Poverty reduction Employment creation Empowerment of marginal groups Social mission and commitment Agent of Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      8
  • 9. Building Inclusive Financial Systems  Microfinance implies building inclusive financial systems that serve the poor  Around the world, over 10,000 MFIs provide funding to 150 million active clients (3/4 women)  66.6 million microfinance clients are among the poorest, living on less than 1 USD per day.  Yet, poor borrowers have proven to be astonishingly creditworthy. Agent of Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      9
  • 10. A High Growth Sector  MFIs manage a loan portfolio estimated at 30 B USD.  The potential demand reaches 263 B USD.  About 500 million microfinance clients have yet to be reached.  The sector enjoys an annual growth of almost 30%.  For investors, microfinance is often considered a special asset class of socially responsible investment, balancing  financial return with  positive social impact.  Traditionally, microfinance grew with the support of government subsidies, donor funding, and grants. Agent of Growth Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      10
  • 11. A High Growth Sector Number of MIVs, 2000-2008  Foreign capital investments in microfinance topped 10 B USD (2008)  103 Microfinance Investment Vehicles (MIVs) claimed an estimated 6.6 B USD in assets under management Source: CGAP 2009 MIV Survey Agent of Growth Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      11
  • 12. A High Growth Sector Growth in Assets, MIVs, 2006-2009  Foreign capital investments in microfinance topped 10 B USD (2008)  103 Microfinance Investment Vehicles (MIVs) claimed an estimated 6.6 B USD in assets under management  MIVs are expected to grow at double-digit rates. Source: CGAP 2009 MIV Survey Agent of Growth Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      12
  • 13. A High Growth Sector with Imbalances Risk Exposure, % of Microfinance Portfolio MIVs, 2006-2008  Funding continues to be widely available and concentrated in the largest 150 MFIs.  Over 40% of the funding provided by MIVs have been allocated to as low as five MFIs only. Source: CGAP 2009 MIV Survey Agent of Growth Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      13
  • 14. A High Growth Sector with Imbalances Regional Distribution of Microfinance Portfolio, MIVs, 2006-2008  Geographic concentration of microfinance funds is also skewed.  Africa and Asia, where poverty and potential demand for microfinance are highest, receive less than 20% of foreign investments. Source: CGAP 2009 MIV Survey Agent of Growth Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      14
  • 15. From Extensive to Intensive Growth  Financial sustainability through professionalization is essential for massively expanding services.  A key bottleneck derives from the shortage of strong institutions and managers.  Many MFIs have experienced extensive growth marked by rapid expansion of branch networks.  Professionalization for intensive growth results from  Productivity gains: economies of scale leading to improved efficiency, reduced transaction costs, and overall profitability;  Innovation: (i) diversified product offerings (e.g. savings, remittance services, micro-insurance, and micro-housing and agricultural loans) and (ii) expanded delivery mechanisms (e.g. mobile banking); and  Improved utilization of organizational capacity. Agent of Growth Professionalization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      15
  • 16. The Commercial Drift of Microfinance  Microfinance enters the mainstream as a profitable business proposition.  This commercialization has increased market competition at both the wholesale and retail levels, to the general benefit of microfinance lenders and borrowers alike.  The entry of private capital has improved access to diversified sources of funding.  With more funding options and higher volume, MFI managers have enhanced their negotiating power and skills to access better financing terms.  Commercialization is necessary to sustain growth in the sector, to scale up outreach, and serve a greater number of financially excluded, low-income people. Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      16
  • 17. The Commercial Drift of Microfinance  A competitive marketplace tends to reduce costs and increase consumer choices.  The push to place significant amounts of additional capital in a limited pool of high-growth MFIs and regions increases the risks of the sector overheating, with  Challenges of managing accelerated growth rates in an increasingly competitive microfinance market;  Uneven management and staffing capacity at MFIs; and  MIVs taking higher exposure with medium-sized MFIs less experienced with commercial borrowing.  Moreover, this migration towards capitalist principles of profit-maximization has increased public scrutiny of the sector. Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      17
  • 18. Microfinance as Sub-subprime  Lax lending practices and weak regulatory oversight, coupled with overabundant funding, can lead to irrational growth. Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      18
  • 19. Microfinance as Sub-subprime  Lax lending practices and weak regulatory oversight, coupled with overabundant funding, can lead to irrational growth.  Commercial pursuit of profits can result in perverse incentives for quantity over quality. Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      19
  • 20. Microfinance as Sub-subprime  Lax lending practices and weak regulatory oversight, coupled with overabundant funding, can lead to irrational growth.  Commercial pursuit of profits can result in perverse incentives for quantity over quality.  Mainstreaming has allowed some MFIs to stray up-market (e.g. consumer, SME, and larger loans with extended tenors). Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      20
  • 21. Microfinance as Sub-subprime  Lax lending practices and weak regulatory oversight, coupled with overabundant funding, can lead to irrational growth.  Commercial pursuit of profits can result in perverse incentives for quantity over quality.  Mainstreaming has allowed some MFIs to stray up-market (e.g. consumer, SME, and larger loans with extended tenors).  Rapid growth and lack of transparent pricing has led to accusations of predatory lending and aggressive collection practices by MFIs. Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      21
  • 22. Microfinance as Sub-subprime  Lax lending practices and weak regulatory oversight, coupled with overabundant funding, can lead to irrational growth.  Commercial pursuit of profits can result in perverse incentives for quantity over quality.  Mainstreaming has allowed some MFIs to stray up-market (e.g. consumer, SME, and larger loans with extended tenors).  Rapid growth and lack of transparent pricing has led to accusations of predatory lending and aggressive collection practices by MFIs.  Over-borrowing on top of high interest rates can produce a cycle of debt that makes the poor worse off. Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      22
  • 23. The Ugly Side of Microlending The unhappy client The bad loan officer  Photos: Kiva Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      23
  • 24. A Victim of Its Own Success Beyond Good Intentions  The success of microfinance has led to more scrutiny of the sector, with increasing pressure to substantiate its social claims and business model.  Microfinance can be over-sold and misleadingly described, with often exaggerated, excessive, and unsupported myths of poverty impact.  With negative media coverage, the industry faces a growing challenge to demonstrate objectively that microfinance is a sound tool for aiding economic and social development.  Mere fact of investing in microfinance is no longer sufficient to demonstrate that an investor is socially responsible. Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      24
  • 25. Limited Evidence of Poverty Alleviation Beyond Good Intentions  Many studies on the impact of microfinance have been plagued by methodological flaws (e.g. selection bias, lack of control groups, measurement of counter-factuals, causal links, descriptive case studies, anecdotal evidence, limitations in data collection).  Rencently, more analytically rigorous studies (e.g. randomized control trials) paint a measured picture of microfinance’s impact on the poor.  There is no scientific evidence to suggest that Microfinance is a transformational tool to lift people out of poverty.  The research findings have been disappointing because the expectations of microfinance were unrealistically high. Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      25
  • 26. Limited Evidence of Poverty Alleviation Beyond Good Intentions  Microfinance has a constructive role to play in the campaign to help the world’s poor.  Its impact is not as large and powerful as some promoters romanticize.  Nor is its contribution in the struggle against poverty as inconsequential as critics dismissively contend.  In general, it is difficult to conduct reliable, scientific testing on the impact of microfinance in a cost-effective way. Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      26
  • 27. Questioning the Faith Re-evaluation of Beyond Good Ethical Principals Intentions  Is microfinance displacing more effective anti-poverty measures?  Will the legitimate drive to maximize profits result in neglect/abuse of the interest of poor clients?  What exactly is sustainable growth in microfinance?  How can the interest of all stakeholders (from borrowers, lenders, third party businesses, and investors) be better balanced?  What lessons can be learned from the pitfalls of sub-prime lending in the US?  How can industry players ensure that microfinance plays a constructive role in alleviating poverty? Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      27
  • 28. Commitment to Benefit Poor People Re-evaluation of Beyond Good Ethical Principals Intentions  Without commercial foundations, microfinance would struggle to become a profitable business needed to survive.  Yet, without firm ethical principles and a strong commitment to benefit the lives of poor people, the sector has no privileged status as a vehicle for socially responsible investing.  There is a growing urgency and moral responsibility to ensure that microfinance contributes to solving social issues and not to maximize profits.  Social investors are demanding evidence of not only financial but also social returns on investments. Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      28
  • 29. Commitment to Benefit Poor People Re-evaluation of Beyond Good Ethical Principals Intentions Do Social Best-in-class MFIs Impact Good Social Do Your Best All MFIs Performance All responsible Consumer Do No Harm financial institutions Protection Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      29
  • 30. Client Protection Principles Assessing Social Re-evaluation of Beyond Good Viability Ethical Principals Intentions  Avoidance of Over-indebtedness  Transparent Pricing  Appropriate Collection Practices  Ethical Staff Behavior  Mechanisms for Redress of Grievances  Privacy of Client Data Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      30
  • 31. Social Performance Management Assessing Social Re-evaluation of Beyond Good Viability Ethical Principals Intentions  Measuring and managing social performance of MFIs help them fulfill their mission and increase the impact on target groups.  The sector has shifted from traditional evaluations (with their focus on end results and impact) to assessing the entire process by which impact is created.  As promoted by the Social Performance Task Force, social performance management strives to make microfinance more effective in achieving its social mission.  Effective Performance Management means the continual process of translating mission and values into practice. Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      31
  • 32. Social Performance Management Principles Assessing Social Re-evaluation of Beyond Good Viability Ethical Principals Intentions MFIs that manage their social performance will deliberately:  Translate its missions and values into clear, measurable objectives to capture intentional social benefits;  Design and implement systems for social responsibility, including client protection;  Track, understand, and report on whether it is achieving its social objectives;  Align its business processes to achieve both social and financial objectives; and  Ensure that decision-making considers both social and financial outcomes. Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      32
  • 33. Contribution of Microfinance Social Impact Assessing Social Re-evaluation of Beyond Good Viability Ethical Principals Intentions  As formal employment opportunities shrink, demand for microcredit grows.  There is strong evidence that poor people value financial services (credit, savings, insurance) as a way to cope with poverty and financial shocks.  Although claims of raising poor people’s income remain unsubstantiated, many microfinance clients tend to use microloans and savings to smooth consumption rather than purely to grow their enterprises.  By working with people in poverty, MFIs have a large capacity to empower them to better manage their own financial affairs. Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      33
  • 34. Influencing the Agenda Social Impact Assessing Social Re-evaluation of Beyond Good Viability Ethical Principals Intentions Social Investors Social Investors Social Investors Tier 2 MFIs Tier 1 MFIs Tier 3 MFIs Agent of Growth Professionalization Commercialization Social Change Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      34
  • 35. The Road Ahead Greater Transparency/Accountability in Realization of Social Goals Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      35
  • 36. The Road Ahead for Social Investments in Microfinance  Recognition of social performance assessment as a completely separate and technically valid area of inclusive finance  Increased social transparency in the microfinance sector  A shift from extensive to more intensive growth  Integration of the assessment of social performance into the regular management systems of MFIs  Social performance and management  No longer viewed as a cost/burden on administrative/operational systems  An opportunity to develop sound and socially viable institutions  Assessment of social performance of social investors  Geographic outreach  Depth (rural/urban, special social group niches, low/high end segment of poverty focus, etc.)  Product diversity Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      36
  • 37. Thank You   Planet Rating Asia 444 EDSA, 21st Floor Guadalupe Viejo Makati 1211, Philippines Tel: +632 897 7992 Fax: +632 897 7992 James Soukamneuth, Ph.D. Asia Office Director jsoukam@planetrating.com Société par Actions Simplifiée with authorized capital of 667,000 EUR. Registration number 483 538 369 RCS Bobigny Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      37
  • 38. Planet Rating The Global Microfinance Rating Agency Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      38
  • 39. Planet Rating: The Global Microfinance Rating Agency Created in 1999 and transformed into a private, independent rating firm in 2005, Planet Rating has over ten years of experience rating microfinance institutions Planet Rating boasts the most extensive global coverage, thanks to a network of 6 offices spread over 4 continents   Paris HQ: covering Eastern Europe   Lima Office: covering Latin America & the Caribbean   Dakar Office: covering West & Central Africa   Nairobi Office: covering East & Southern Africa   Beirut Office: covering Middle East & North Africa   Manila Office: covering Asia Offices Missions Qualified & experienced team   Each senior analyst has conducted at least 12 rating missions on 3 different continents   Analyst backgrounds: investment banking, management consulting, non-profit, microfinance Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      39
  • 40. GIRAFE Methodology Powerful framework to understand an MFI’s risk profile and evaluate its institutional sustainability   Created in 1999, it is the most comprehensive and transparent rating methodology   Certified and accredited by CGAP and the ADA Rating Initiative   Widely recognized worldwide by investors, donors, regulators and microfinance consultants   Specifically designed and adapted to microfinance, relevant to suit all types, sizes and stages of development of MFIs   Proven and stable methodology already employed for more than 410 ratings in over 65 countries   An enhanced GIRAFE methodology was finalized in January 2008 in order to anticipate future microfinance rating risks and challenges Rating Domains Weightings G overnance 24% Qualitative I nformation 10% domains R isk 10% A ctivities 20% F unding and liquidity Quantitative 14% domains E fficiency and 22% profitability Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      40
  • 41. A Full Range of GIRAFE-based Rating Products I) GIRAFE Institutional Rating   Comprehensive analysis of the MFI risk profile and organizational performance   Valuable tool for mature MFIs in search of new financing and greater international visibility II) Social Performance Rating   Evaluation of the MFI’s ability to reach its social mission and objectives   Identification of strengths and weaknesses of its social performance management system III) GIRAFE Interactive Assessment   Interactive approach to the rating analysis that includes training   Management and internal communication tool for young MFIs in search of technical assistance and donor funding IV) GIRAFE Training Module   Theoretical and practical training with case studies over the course of 2-3 days   Flexible content and modules suitable for all kinds of participants, regardless of prior knowledge of microfinance Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      41
  • 42. Large experience in Latin America Guatemala Dominican Republic Mexico  FUNDAP  ECLOF  11 MFIs: ADMIC, Caja Cresciencio Cruz, CONSERVA, Haïti Despeno, Durango, Empredamos Juntos,  COD/MEH FOCRECE, PEN, Santa Fe de Guanajuato, Semisol, Brazil Unicreich  17 MFIs: Banco da Familia, BluSol Brésil, Casa do Nicaragua Microcredito,CEADe BRAZIL,  3 MFIs: 20 de Abril, FODEM, CEAPE / MA, CEAPE / PB, FUNDENUSE CEAPE / PE, CEAPE / PI, CEAPE / RN, CEAPE / SE, CEAPE PI, Credisol, CRESOL, Ecuador PortoSol, RioCred,  1 MFI: Fundamic SOCIALCRED, VivaCred  20 ratings Peru  11 MFIs: CAC Santa Maria de Bolivia la Magdalena, COOPAC San 10 MFIs: ANED, CIDRE, Martín de Porres, COOPAC CRECER, Crédito Amigo, Tochache, Epydme DIACONIA, Eco futuro, Alternativa, Prisma, Finca, Chile FADES, FONDECO, FONDESURCO, GCOD, FUBODE, IMPRO  1 Bank: Banco del Arariwa, Caritas Felices Desarrollo  14 ratings  15 ratings Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      42
  • 43. Excellent track record in the MENA region Jordan Morocco  3 MFIs: AMC, JMCC, MFW  9 MFIs: Al Amana, Al  6 ratings Karama, Amos, AMSSF/ MC, FCAMC, FONDEP, INMAA, Ismailia, Palestine Zakoura  8 MFIs: ACAD, Alrafah,  20 ratings Asala, FATEN, PDF, PARC- SCA, UNRWA, YMCA-SED  8 ratings Tunisia Egypt Yemen  1 MFI: Enda  7 MFIs: ABA, Al Tadamun,  1 MFI: Hodeidah ASBA, DBACD, Lead Microfinance Program  2 ratings Foundation, SBACD, FMF  1 rating  10 ratings Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      43
  • 44. The Leading Rating Agency in Sub-Saharan Africa Mali: Kafo Jiginew, FCRMD, Jemeni, Kondo Niger: ASUSU, MCPEC, Ethiopia: OCSSCO, PEACE, Jigima, Misélini, Niako, CVECA ON, Nyeta UMEC, MECREF, Albarka Buusaa Gonofaa, SFPI, Eshet, Musow, Piyeli, Soro Yriwaso, PASECA SA, Yarda Zinder, Yarda Wasasa, AVFS, Harbu, Kayes, RMCR, Nyesigiso Madaoua Metemamen Kenya: EBS, SMEP, ECLOF, Senegal: UMECU, SISDO, Yehu, PAWDEP, AAR, PAMECAS, ACEP, Delta, Ebony Foundation AFER, Caurie, Tostan Uganda: UML, HOFOKAM, SMS, Burkina: RCPB, UCEC- FOCCAS, Ugafode, Terudet, Z, URCCOM, URCBAM SAO-MFI and 10 SACCOs Ghana: SAT, APED, Rwanda: COOPEDU, CRAN, ECLOF Ghana Duterimbere, ACB, CAF Isonga and 9 rural banks; Madagascar: Otiv de la Sava, Benin: Vital Finance, PAPME, PADME, Vola Mahasoa FINADEV, FICA, FENACREP, Convergence 2000, CNACFD, CBDIBA, ASSEF South Africa: Marang, Kuyasa Fund, NBF, Tiisha Tanzania: SELFINA; Mozambique: Socremo Bank, Burundi: COSPEC; Malawi: CUMO; Zambia: CETZAM; Comoros: Sanduk; Central Africa Republic: CMCA, Ivory Coast: CICA, Chad: UCEC Pala, Gambia: GAWFA; Guinea Conakry: PRIDE, CRG; Cameroon: CDM, ACEP, SAILD, COMECI, SOFINA; Togo: WAGES, TIMPAC, SEBADERS, UMECTO; Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      44
  • 45. Diversified experience in Eastern Europe and Central Asia Bosnia Herzegovina Ukraine Russia  10 MFIs: Mikrofin,  HOPE  5 MFIs: FFECCC, RWMN, Benefit, EKI, LOK micro, VRFSBS, Doveriye, Mi-Bospo, Partner, Narodnyi Prizma, Sunrise, Women  7 ratings for Women, Sinergija Plus  23 ratings Serbia Montenegro  AgroInvest  3 ratings Mongolia  2 Banks: Khan Bank, Bulgaria Xac Bank  Easy Credit  1 MFI: VisionFund Mongolia Kosovo Tadjikistan  KEP  1 Bank: Bank Eskhata Azerbaijan Moldova Georgia Armenia  AzerdemyriolBank  MicroInvest  Constanta AzeriStar  3 MFIs: Aregak, MDF-  3 ratings  2 ratings Kamurj, Nor Horizon  3 ratings Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      45
  • 46. Growing experience in Asia Mongolia China  2 Banks: Khan Bank, Xac Bank  Industry diagnostic  1 MFI: VisionFund Mongolia  Training  Interactive Assessment (Harbin Bank) Afghanistan  1 MFI: Sunduq Vietnam  3 MFIs: CEP, TYM Fund, Binh Minh India  5 ratings  3 MFIs: ASA Grama Vidiyal, LEAD, SWC Cambodia  5 MFIs: CREDIT, Vision Indonesia Philippines Fund Cambodia, TPC,  Ratings of 5 Cooperatives,  8 MFIs: CARD, LifeBank, Seilanithih, CCSF including KOMIDA PMPC, CEVI, GM Bank,  9 ratings ECLOF, HSPFI, SEDP   Workshop Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      46
  • 47. Contacts   Global Headquarters   Middle East & North Africa 13 rue Dieumegard Picadilly Bldg #407 93400 Saint-Ouen Paris – France Hamra Street Tel: +33 1 4921 2630 Beirut – Lebanon Fax: +33 1 4921 2627 Tel: +961 3 11 96 81   Latin America   West Africa & Central Africa Francisco de Paula Ugarriza 813 – Oficina 301 Boulevard Djily Mbaye Miraflores, Lima 18 – Peru Immeuble FADH, 14th floor Tel: +51 1 242 4597 BP 5695 Dakar – Senegal Fax: +51 1 242 4597 Tel/Fax: +221 33 821 79 39   Asia   East Africa & Southern Africa 444 EDSA 21st floor, Guadalupe Viejo Shelter Afrique House – Mamlaka Road 1211 Makati, Manila – Philippines PO Box 16658, 00100 Nairobi – Kenya Tel/Fax: +632 897 7992 Tel: +254 20 271 42 20 www.planetrating.com - rating@planetrating.com Microfinance Investment Landscape and the Growth of Social Investments      47