Carola York from Jellyfish Publishing gave a presentation on improving subscription marketing ROI in 2013. She discussed how the digital marketing landscape is shifting to mobile and how PPC campaigns need to reflect this. York provided tips on optimizing campaigns for different devices and on using remarketing techniques like Google Display ads and Facebook Custom Audiences to reconnect with past website visitors. Initial results showed these approaches can generate high conversion rates.
2. Carola York
Managing Director, Jellyfish Publishing
Jellyfish are a digital marketing agency, renowned for their expertise in PPC.
Jellyfish Publishing is a standalone business division within the Jellyfish Group,
dedicated to serving its numerous publishing clients. It works in partnership with
publishers to create digital campaigns which generate new subscribers - on a risk-
free Cost per Acquisition model.
I joined Jellyfish Publishing last year following 25 years working for a range of
consumer and business-to-business publishers – both big and small - including
The Spectator, EMAP, The Tablet, TSL Education, The Economist and IPC.
As a specialist in subscription marketing, I help Jellyfish’s publishing clients grow
their print, digital and app subscription businesses.
2 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
3. What I’m covering today...
• Some of the latest techniques Jellyfish Publishing are using to help grow subscription sales from PPC
for our publishing clients - across mobile, tablet and desktop devices.
• A brief run through how Google’s latest offering for app analytics can help you measure ROI and return
from your app marketing budget.
• What’s new in the social media marketing world - a look at Facebook Custom Audiences and Facebook
Exchange .
3 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
4. What’s new in PPC?
4 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
5. The search landscape is going through a major shift
• People using their mobiles and
tablets to search the web is
continuing to rise exponentially.
• 46% of Christmas Day search
traffic was on tablets and mobiles.
• Mobile web browsing is
predicted to overtake desktop in
2014. That’s next year!
5 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
6. What does this mean if you are selling subscriptions
through PPC?
• Search on mobile, tablet and desktop need to
be managed and tracked separately.
• People use them in different ways – at
different times of the day – to buy different
things.
• So the PPC activity you run must reflect this to
ensure you get the best response and return on
your marketing spend.
6 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
7. Understand how people visit your site
• What traffic comes from desktop, tablet and mobile? At what time of day?
Visits by Hour of Day
1600 500
1400 450
400
1200
350
1000 300
Desktop
800 250
200 Mobile/Tablet
600
150
400
100
200 50
0 0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23
7 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
8. Allocate your budget appropriately
• Allocate your budget - using Ad Scheduling - to the most appropriate devices at different points in
the day.
8 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
9. Use different messaging and call-to-actions
• If your website is not particularly mobile friendly, test using ad messages such as ‘click to call’ to
get people calling in to order (otherwise they might just give up placing an online order via their
mobile).
• Or if it is mobile/tablet friendly, use ad messages such as ‘... on your tablet’, and ‘mobile friendly’ to
encourage people to click through to order.
• If you find getting people to sign up via mobiles is difficult, test promoting your mobile app (if you
have one) instead of a print subscription – otherwise you’ll be paying for lots of clicks and getting few
orders.
9 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
10. Consider using Call Extensions
But ensure your call centre or subscription bureau log the ‘source’ of the call - or use
Jellyfish’s Infinity call tracking service which can attribute the call back to the individual
keyword.
10 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
11. For apps, test using Mobile App extensions
These drive people directly to your app - in either the Apple App store or in Google Play.
11 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
12. Don’t assume mobile/tablet users want to only buy apps
• In Jellyfish’s experience, even though someone is
searching on a mobile or tablet, they are still more likely to
want to buy a print subscription.
• So, give the customer the choice – print, digital, or app
subscription, depending on your offering – in order to
maximise your potential number of subscription sales.
12 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
13. Using PPC to market apps
• Google Analytics is great for analysing website traffic -
and Google AdWords is great for managing PPC.
• But until now it has been impossible to track paid app
sales (made within an app) directly back to PPC
keywords, unless you’ve set up your own custom
tracking.
• It’s therefore been impossible to measure an accurate
ROI from your app marketing spend on PPC.
13 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
14. Launch of Google Mobile App Analytics
• Google has recently taken a big step forward with the
launch of their Mobile App Analytics package.
• This is great news if you sell an Android app through
Google Play!
• But sadly Google doesn’t yet support the tracking of
Magazines sold through Google Play.
• Nor does it support the tracking of sales made in iOS
iPhone and iPad apps.
14 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
15. About Google Mobile App Analytics
• It allows you to capture usage data about your Android app - and integrate it with your Google
Analytics account.
• The suite of reports available provides metrics which
can help you evaluate the performance of your app
including:
• the number of downloads/installations
• the devices and networks used to access the app
• the geographic location and languages spoken by visitors
And most importantly...
• in-app purchases
15 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
16. Tracking in-app purchases
• If you want to track the all important data related to single or subscription sales of your app, you’ll
need to make sure you set up the ‘ecommerce tracking’ option.
• Once set up you’ll then be able to see reports on:
• in-app revenue
• total number of transactions
• the percentage of sessions that included a transaction
• the average value of transactions within the app
• the total quantity sold
• the number of unique purchases
16 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
17. What’s new in remarketing?
17 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
18. What is remarketing?
• When people visit your website, but leave
without buying, remarketing lets you reconnect
with these prospects and entice them to return
and buy a subscription.
The main remarketing options available include:
• Email
• Text and image ads served via the Google Display network – launched in March 2010
• NEW! Facebook Custom Audiences – launched in September 2012
• NEW! Facebook Exchange – launched in September 2012
18 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
19. Remarketing via Google
• Google allows you to target people who have visited
your website – and it then display your ads on other
websites they subsequently visit.
• You simply need to add a small snippet of code from
AdWords onto the pages of your website – and then
launch your AdWords campaign.
• Does it deliver a good ROI for subscriptions?
• YES!
19 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
20. Ensure you minimise the feeling of being ‘stalked’
• A basic Adwords remarketing campaign will follow your
prior site visitors across the web, serving the same ads over
and over again on any of the web pages they visit.
• Both excessive ad repetition (and presence on subsequent
visited sites which might have inappropriate or irrelevant
content) can contribute to the feeling of being stalked.
• So you need to think carefully about how you set up
remarketing to maximise your return – but minimise the
intrusion.
20 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
21. Top tips for success
1. Create different audience groups by considering:
• Which page on the site did they leave from?
• Had they been looking at general content – or a subscription specific page?
• Did they start the subscription sign up process, but not complete it?
2. Create different ad messages (and maybe offers) for each audience group . Consider that
they visited your site, but left. Why? What might entice them back?
• A reminder of the latest subscription offer (if they started the sign up process but didn’t complete it)?
• A reduced price offer if they just visited the subs page and then left?
• If they looked only at editorial content, why not just get them signed up for something – a free e-newsletter – to
allow you to contact them with a subscription offer in future.
21 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
22. Top tips for success
3. Decide where the ad clicks through to.
• An existing page on your site? Or a new, customised landing page – reflecting the ad message/ offer?
4. Consider when to serve the ads – and for how long.
• Do you want ads to be shown immediately after someone visited your site. Or delay when they are served? How
many times do you want them to appear? Between 7 and 12 is generally recommended.
5. Consider which categories that you may want to exclude.
• Juvenile, gross & bizarre content? Profanity & rough language? Sexually suggestive content?
6. Test. Analyse. Refine.
22 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
23. Options for both text and image ads
Text
Image
23 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
24. Great for brand awareness – and subscriptions
Here are some recent results for remarketing campaigns run by Jellyfish Publishing run
for a couple of our magazine clients:
Impressions Clicks Click Cost Subscriptions Cost Conversion View Cost
through Per rate through Per
rate Acquisition subscriptions Acquisition
Text 643,582 1,686 0.26% £891.02 24 £37.13 1.42% 0 £37.13
Image 220,904 465 0.21% £273.06 17 £16.06 3.66% 99 £2.35
Impressions Clicks Click Cost Subscriptions Cost Conversion View Cost
through Per rate through Per
rate Acquisition subscriptions Acquisition
Text 44,936 93 0.21% £31.62 1 £31.62 1.08% 0 £31.62
Image 155,490 291 0.19% £112.28 5 £22.46 1.72% 49 £2.08
24 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
25. facebook’s Custom Audiences
• Advertising on facebook can be good for brand awareness, but in
our experience, is often difficult to generate any reasonable volume
of subscriptions to justify the effort or spend involved.
• facebook’s recent launch of Custom Audiences provides a new
opportunity to target just people you have had contact with before –
a form of remarketing .
• And early reports from those testing it show it is has the potential
to generate between 5 and 25 times more return than the standard
facebook interest targeting. Great news!
25 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
26. How it works
• If you have email or phone lists (collected via your website, from events you run , from lapsed subs
lists etc), it allows you to just serve an ad to just these people - in facebook.
• It’s run through the Power Editor function in facebook (you can’t manage custom audiences
through the standard Ads Editor).
• You upload your list – it’s hashed to keep it secure and facebook don’t keep or pass on your data.
• facebook then match your list of contacts against all their active users – finding the people who
have the same email or phone number – and then serve the ad just to them.
26 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
27. What to consider?
1. Understand who is in your list of contacts.
• How did you gather the list?
• How long ago?
• How much do they already know about your publication?
2. Ensure your ads – and offers – are then designed to attract the people on each specific list.
• Don’t use one generic ad for all lists.
• Reflect their knowledge of your publication - and use the offer most likely to attract them to sign up.
3. Create ads for facebook’s mobile newsfeed.
• Mobile newsfeed ads generally achieve higher response rates.
27 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
28. What to consider?
4. Consider where your ad will click through to.
• Keeping people within the facebook environment usually generates a better response than directing them
to a website.
• Can you create a sign up page on your facebook page?
5. Make your sign up form as mobile-friendly as possible
• 19 million of the UK’s 27 million facebook population access it via their mobiles
6. Test. Analyse. Refine.
28 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
29. Ideas to test
• Reactivate registered website users who have not visited your
site for some time – encourage them to sign up for a free trial.
• Tempt lapsed subscribers back with a really strong
subscription offer.
• Entice ‘abandoned baskets’ to go back and complete their
order.
• Encourage people to download your mobile app (perfect for
mobile newsfeed ads!)
29 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
30. Facebook Exchange
• Facebook Exchange (FBX) allows you to re-market to
Facebook users who have already visited your website. So, as
with other remarketing, should lead to high conversion rates
and a good return on investment.
• Initial results from across the digital marketing industry
show click-to-conversion rates of 8-10% (compared to the 4-
6% maximum usually seen from standard facebook display
ads) .
30 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
31. The Pros and Cons
The Pros
• It could offer a great opportunity to generate additional subscriptions at a good ROI.
• It compliments all the other remarketing you might have in place.
• It offers high quality inventory – all impressions are above the fold and remain viewable regardless of how
the user scrolls.
The Cons
• You can only serve ads on the right-hand side of facebook on desktop – they don’t appear in mobile
newsfeeds.
• You have to work through a 3rd party. Facebook Exchange is currently only available through the digital
marketing software of approved partners and most charge minimum fees.
31 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
32. In summary
32 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
33. Top tips
1. Understand what traffic comes to your site from desktop, tablet and mobile – at what time of
day.
2. Test different ad messaging and calls-to-action in your PPC, depending on the device.
3. Offer customers the choice of a print, digital or app subscription – regardless of the device
they are using to visit your site.
4. If you have an Android app, investigate how Google Mobile App Analytics can help you track
your app marketing ROI.
5. Make sure you are running remarketing campaigns via Google as they are great for both brand
awareness and subscription generation.
6. Test facebook’s new Custom Audiences offering.
33 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
34. For further information
About Jellyfish Publishing’s services, visit: www.jellyfishpublishing.co.uk
About Infinity Call Tracking, visit: www.infinity-tracking.com
About Google’s Mobile App Analytics, visit: www.google.com/analytics/features/mobile.html
About facebook Custom Audiences, visit: www.facebook.com/help/459892990722543/
34 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
35. Follow Jellyfish Publishing
Twitter: @JFPublishing
Jellyfish Publishing
35 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013
36. Thank you
Carola York Jellyfish House
Managing Director London Road
01737 749673 Reigate
carola.york@jellyfishpublishing.co.uk Surrey RH2 9SS
37. Q&A
37 Carola York, Jellyfish Publishing | Specialist Media Presentation | 6 February 2013